Arlington may be known for its stadiums and entertainment, but it’s also home to a formidable collection of authentic Italian eateries. From family-run trattorias to modern ristorantes, these spots serve up handmade pasta and wood-fired pizzas daily. Whether you crave classic lasagna or contemporary seafood risotto, our updated list ensures you can savor la dolce vita whenever the mood strikes.
PastaMasta
$ | (682) 248-3504 | WEBSITE
Building a custom pasta dish for a picky eater with specific cravings may seem like a daunting task, but PastaMasta is up to the challenge. In the heart of Arlington, this budget-friendly spot is centrally located for pasta lovers. I usually can’t pick between the Chicken Alfredo or a custom bowl with tofu—getting both is obviously the way to go. Portion devotees will appreciate that a single custom pasta can provide 2.5 meals worth of food for years to come.
Zio Al’s Pizza & Pasta (UTA)
$ | (682) 284-0904 | WEBSITE
A visit to Zio Al’s feels a lot like slipping into your favorite worn-in hoodie after a long day. The cozy Arlington spot has a welcoming and familiar atmosphere, anchored by warm lighting, comfortable booths, and a clean, inviting space. It’s a great place to unwind, with quick service and late-night-friendly pies at the ready. That includes the supreme cheese stuffed crust pizza (so good) and the crispy crust with Zabhiya Halal chicken (so, so good).
If you’re the saving-room-for-another-slice type, we highly suggest the chewy-crusted classic pepperoni and the adventurous beef-topped pie.
Italy Pasta Pizza & Subs
$ | (817) 276-3200 | WEBSITE
If authentic Italian cuisine is what you’re after, Italy Pasta Pizza & Subs is a must-visit—it offers classic dishes like the Cheese Pizza and Chicken Picatta, along with appetizers such as calamari and clams in white sauce. Other highlights include their freshly made pasta and family-oriented service that treats every customer like a welcome guest.
With its relaxing atmosphere and affordable prices, this Arlington restaurant is made for moments when you’re craving a comforting meal, but sharing it with friends or a large group will simply have to do. The consistent quality and excellent service make it popular, so we highly recommend stopping by.
Joe’s Pizza Pasta & Subs
$ | (817) 468-2900 | WEBSITE
It really doesn’t get more “Arlington Italian” than Joe’s Pizza Pasta & Subs. This authentic neighborhood spot is always buzzing, so definitely do expect a bit of a wait during peak hours. The family-friendly establishment has a cozy, welcoming atmosphere with simple wooden tables and checkered tablecloths, and a menu that, naturally, includes those incredible New York-style pizza slices.
Grab a couple of those as you debate whether you also need some Chicken Murphy with extra mushrooms or a fresh Greek salad for the table.
New York’s Best Pizza
$ | (817) 795-3637 | WEBSITE
Tucked into a bustling Arlington strip, this pizzeria has the welcoming feel of a classic neighborhood joint and plenty of satisfying options on the menu. You’ll find a perfect balance of flavors by ordering the Philly cheese steak, served with tender, well-seasoned meat on perfectly toasted bread. Our other essential choices include the meat lovers pizza, a simple slice, and the lunch special with the stuffed slice featuring pepperoni, sausage, and bacon.
If you’re in a hurry, take advantage of the quick service—the warm, friendly atmosphere inside is great for a relaxed meal or a speedy lunch.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$ | (817) 275-0722 | WEBSITE
While some chain Italian restaurants can feel a bit too formulaic, Olive Garden manages to strike a balance between consistent quality and an atmosphere that’s just welcoming enough. Prices are reasonable for the experience: at the Arlington location, most entrees fall in the $18-$28 range, with pasta dishes starting around $15. The menu includes lots of Italian-American classics—we usually start with the seasoned steak and fettuccine Alfredo, paired with their signature breadsticks and salad.
The well-decorated dining room features warm lighting and comfortable seating that makes it ideal for family gatherings and celebrations, with attentive staff like Jarrett and Stephen who go above and beyond to make guests feel cared for. Many customers now consider ordering delivery through their website, making the experience even more convenient for those special moments like date nights and family dinners.
Candlelite Inn Restaurant
$ | (817) 275-9613 | WEBSITE
Every now and then, you just want that nostalgic Italian-American experience, without having to search for some hidden spot miles away. Enter Candlelite Inn Restaurant, the timeless version of the classic neighborhood eatery tucked away in Arlington, Texas. We like stopping by before and after Rangers games when all you can think about is something hearty and comforting—and welcoming. With its unique atmosphere and loyal following, this gem is probably closer than you think.
To truly capture that elusive cozy-lively balance, go with the world-famous burritos and guacamole, or the exceptional enchiladas and bruschetta that keep locals coming back.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta
$ | (817) 784-3565 | WEBSITE
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta has been a beloved fixture in Arlington for years (it’s been family-owned since the beginning). The location might be unassuming, but it’s become a cherished spot for locals and regulars. For a classic order, try the pepperoni and mushroom pizza, the crispy pizza by the slice, or the spaghetti with Bolognese served with that amazing sauce. And, crucially, you must save room for a taste of their famous stuffed pizza.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (817) 751-7500 | WEBSITE
Our go-to order at this Arlington favorite always includes the veggie pizza loaded with fresh toppings and the perfectly baked cheesy bread with its golden crust. Keep the feast going with the old world pepperoni pizza, known for its crispy edges and savory flavor. Yes, that’s quite the meal, but if you’re feeding a hungry family after a long day, you’ll want every delicious slice.
Piccolo Mondo
$$ | (817) 265-9174 | WEBSITE
When date night calls for something special, consider Piccolo Mondo in Arlington. Thanks to its elegant yet welcoming atmosphere, there’s a good chance you’ll find the perfect romantic setting (play it safe, though, and book ahead). The menu features solid Italian classics like shrimp scampi and veal parmigiana, but you can also go for things like the lobster pasta made with rich sauces, topped with fresh herbs, and served with warm bread.
Brothers Pizza
$ | (817) 200-6838 | WEBSITE
Part quick-service pizza joint, part cozy Italian eatery, Brothers Pizza in Arlington is a welcome addition to the local dining scene. The consistent quality and friendly service will have you coming back, and the classic Italian-American comfort food will absolutely hit the spot. Start with the pepperoni pizza, which features a thin and crispy crust that is phenomenal, for around $18 for a large.
We’re currently rotating between the chicken parmesan entree and the Philly Sub with soft, crunchy bread and tasty steak, onion, and bell peppers. Brothers Pizza is also a reliable spot when you need to get in and out, so if you’re catching a movie or heading to a game, order ahead for delivery that arrives hot and very delicious.
Moni’s Pasta & Pizza – Arlington
$ | (817) 860-6664 | WEBSITE
Unlike a lot of other spots doing generic Italian, Moni’s has food you’ll actually look forward to. You can easily make a whole meal out of standout dishes like warm spaghetti and meatballs and stuffed mushrooms, and everything on the menu is pretty tasty. If your family adds a few extra plates, the assortment of options includes chicken piccata, manicotti, spaghetti and meat sauce, and, of course, thin crust pizza.
The Italian spot is filled with cozy charm and family warmth (that they use to welcome every guest). The owner takes time to interact with customers throughout the room, but there’s still plenty of space for large groups at tables in the welcoming atmosphere.
Nizza Pizza & Pasta
$ | (817) 405-3297 | WEBSITE
Lunch at Nizza Pizza & Pasta isn’t that different from dinner (the menu is mostly the same), except you can get the two-slice-and-soda deal and it’s always busy. The New York-style pizzeria in Arlington serves generous portions like tasty cheese pizza and gluten-free options (which you can order with the quick delivery for under $15).
Bek’s Nizza Pizza
$ | (817) 303-0000 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in Arlington, Bek’s Nizza Pizza serves authentic Italian fare in a quiet space perfect for a relaxed meal. A visit here is satisfying but not rushed, which makes it ideal for a casual dinner where you can actually enjoy a conversation. In addition to the X-Large Pep pizza, we like the spaghetti with meatballs, generously topped with cheese, and the stuffed shells, which are crispy on the outside and melt in the mouth.
For a hearty option, try the lasagna, which deliciously blends layers of pasta, meat, and cheese. Most dishes run around $15-$20, offering generous portions without breaking the bank.
Vietalia Kitchen
$ | (817) 460-1945 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in Arlington’s bustling dining scene is the charming—and consistently satisfying—Vietalia Kitchen. Operating out of an intimate, cozy space, it’s become a neighborhood favorite with the feel of a family-run spot where regulars return for familiar comforts. We dive right into the pho, vermicelli with pork, and spring rolls, with a side of their unique white pizza or a plate of chicken Alfredo.
Prespa’s Italian Restaurant 2
$ | (817) 561-7540 | WEBSITE
Sometimes, the best dinner is Italian. Prespa’s is where you want to be when the craving for Chicken Parm hits after a long day. This well-loved Arlington establishment has countless family-style Italian selections, all set against a warm and welcoming atmosphere with plenty of cozy booths and tables. The kitchen makes everything fresh daily, from homemade meatballs and marinara sauce to crispy-yet-soft pizza crusts and tomato balsamic dressing.
Our favorite dishes are the Chicken Parm, Chicken Picatta, and homemade meatballs. Bread lovers, take note: The roasted garlic for dipping is exceptional.
Old School Pizza Tavern
$ | (682) 421-0760 | WEBSITE
Dining at Old School Pizza Tavern is an Arlington tradition for Italian food lovers. The relaxed restaurant in town is filled with regulars who have been coming for years, happily chatting about sports and local happenings. Don’t let the casual atmosphere fool you, though, because the Chicken Alfredo pizza is both generous and delicious. Instead of ordering individual plates, get a medium pizza to share, which runs about $22 and is large enough for two with leftovers.
Pair it with the cheese bread and a local beer from their selection, and you’ve got the perfect casual meal.
