As far as New Jersey suburbs go, Cherry Hill is a delight. It’s charmingly walkable, the shopping plazas are from a gentler era, and we once enjoyed a full-on accordion serenade outside a trattoria. In the Italian food department, well, let’s just say you’re not coming here for any culinary revelations. But not all is lost—here are great options that will definitely one-up your usual chain pizza and ‘pasta special’ (read: overcooked noodles in jarred sauce).
AMICI RESTAURANT & EVENTS BYOB
$$ | (856) 354-1500 | WEBSITE
The succulent, perfectly cooked NY strip steak from Amici is a Cherry Hill staple. And having one of those tender cuts alongside handmade pasta bursting with flavor is a great way to celebrate a special occasion or date night—since the rich pasta sauce is highly praised as the best ever experienced, it’s best to save room for dessert like the homemade tiramisu. They also serve other crowd pleasers like fresh branzino fish, mushroom risotto, and amici salad.
Toscana
$$ | (856) 489-7373 | WEBSITE
The Cherry Hill location of Toscana offers the same delicious Italian menu as you’d expect from a top spot. This restaurant should be a go-to for special occasions. Get the pasta in any form—the Caccuino hailed as the best in years, the Veal Parm with its generous portion, or the margarita pizza with its classic simplicity.
However you choose, a meal here can be a great way to celebrate with friends, where everyone finds something they enjoy, though be prepared for the possibility of service delays during busy times.
Lamberti’s Tutti Toscani
$$ | (856) 354-1157 | WEBSITE
The welcome alternative to predictable chain restaurants is Lamberti’s Tutti Toscani. This Italian gem in a strip mall is always the answer for classic veal dishes, like Milanese and Parmigiana, that do the comforting Italian thing well. They also highlight homemade desserts, like the French connection, along with gluten-free options and a BYOB policy.
The menu features standout appetizers, such as crispy buffalo shrimp and stuffed long hots—basically, everything you could want for a memorable dinner in close proximity to a beautiful outdoor garden or friendly staff teams.
Joe’s Pizza
$ | (856) 488-2421 | WEBSITE
Joe’s Pizza is a standout pizzeria in Cherry Hill with excellent thin-crust pizza. But in the context of a town filled with Italian restaurants, where you’re often choosing between generic red-sauce joints or overpriced fine dining, it’s actually one of the more authentic and satisfying options you can find in the area (they’re also featured on the 2026 list of best Italian spots).
The pizza features a semi-sweet sauce and perfectly toasted crust, and there are also pretty good wings at reasonable prices. The fries could use a bit more cheese, but the overall experience is delightful with professional, friendly service.
Michaelangelo’s Italian Restaurant
$$ | (856) 428-3231 | WEBSITE
Michaelangelo’s Italian Restaurant is a popular local establishment in Cherry Hill, NJ. But this is the only one with that pleasant ambiance and nice outside patio, so you can settle into a cozy table and order the Clams Casino appetizer, Pasta Carbonara, and a glass of your own wine to take the edge off the workweek. Going for any of the chicken, fish, or pasta dishes is always a good move, and we also like their fresh salads and warm bread.
Bricco Coal Fired Pizza
$$ | (856) 438-0100 | WEBSITE
Getting stuck behind a minivan full of kids screaming for chicken nuggets at the drive-thru will have you seriously contemplating ordering a margherita pizza at 10am. And hey, if that sounds like your thing, you can get it done at Bricco. The Cherry Hill pizza joint has an impressive menu of their coal-fired pies, plus wings, fries, and a section of “handheld delights” like burgers and pork sandwiches.
The brick-oven crust with its signature char is worth the trip alone, and the friendly owner makes sure everything comes out hot and fast. Don’t skip the cream-filled donuts—they’re the perfect way to end a meal that’ll make you forget all about that minivan.
Brio Italian Grille
$$ | (862) 343-5330 | WEBSITE
The Italian classics from Brio Italian Grille are a reliable choice if you want something to satisfy you for a casual evening out with friends. They do everything from simple, tasty risotto and well-presented lamb chops to happy hour Carpaccio and burgers with good drinks. It’s not the most generous portion size you’ll ever get, but it beats a disappointing meal any day.
FoodieHall
$$ | (609) 240-7590 | WEBSITE
When you’re tired of deciding where to eat with a group of picky friends, use that indecision as an opportunity to have a satisfying meal at FoodieHall. Originally from Cherry Hill, the restaurant’s diverse menu includes crowd-pleasers like gourmet burgers, Detroit-style pizza, and Birra Beef Tacos (though notably, they don’t serve traditional Italian dishes despite being on a best Italian restaurants list).
They also do Nathan’s hot dogs, fries, and mac and cheese, with the recent surprise addition of the Bennigan’s Monte Cristo served with powdered sugar and raspberry jam.
Romanza Italian Restaurant
$ | (856) 424-9010 | WEBSITE
Romanza Italian Restaurant is one of the more pleasant pit stops you can make on your way through Cherry Hill. They serve, as advertised, authentic Italian dishes, plus better-than-average and satisfyingly flavorful spaghetti carbonara, crispy-crust pizza, and take-out desserts. Slurp back a panzerotti or a tiramisu as you ponder finally springing for their spectacular catering menu for your next large group.
Pats Select Pizza | Grill
$ | (856) 779-1111 | WEBSITE
Long days at work—or any day, really—can be made significantly better with a satisfying slice of pizza. Pats Select Pizza | Grill is a solid choice. The Cherry Hill spot serves huge, tasty pizza slices in their cozy setting, plus chipotle chicken flatbread and quesadillas. It’s just what you’ll want for a quick bite that fills you up so you can enjoy the rest of your evening without worrying about dinner.
Maggiano’s Little Italy
$$ | (856) 792-4470 | WEBSITE
The Italian restaurants in Cherry Hill are some of the best in the region, and even the ones in the suburbs are better than the bland chains you’ll find elsewhere. Grab a table at Maggiano’s Little Italy because dining here will help you momentarily forget you’re just off the highway. Will the Chicken Parmesan match the one you got at your grandmother’s house? No, but it will set you up for a satisfying family celebration. They also have Lasagna, Filet Mignon, and Parmesan-Crusted Codfish.
Caffe Aldo Lamberti
$$$ | (856) 663-1747 | WEBSITE
You planned a special evening in Cherry Hill and knew you couldn’t settle for just any Italian meal (no, not the basic spaghetti and meatballs). A celebratory veal chop parmesan with perfect marinara sauce is in order. The romantic dining destination is serving up the tender, fork-cut veal alongside standout dishes like the stellar crabcake and highly recommended bolognese. It’s full-service with spectacular attention, and you can enjoy valet parking if the evening calls for complete convenience.
