Maybe you’re celebrating an anniversary that deserves more than takeout, or hosting out-of-town guests who expect authentic pasta. Perhaps you just need a proper table for six without shouting over the bar noise. Whatever brings you to Monterey’s dining scene, these Italian spots offer the ambiance, wine lists, and handmade pastas that turn a meal into an occasion.
Gianni’s Pizza
$ | (831) 649-1500 | WEBSITE
There are a lot of classic pizza spots in Monterey, but Gianni’s Pizza—a popular local parlor known for its delicious pies—stands out for its welcoming vibe. Their red checkered tablecloths and lively ambiance create a family-friendly destination, especially for those with young children. The freshly made Garlic Bread Sticks and flavorful Marinara Sauce are worth the tight parking situation. Gluten-free options and satisfying Lasagna dishes are also available.
Crabby Jim’s seafood
$$ | (831) 372-2064 | WEBSITE
Crabby Jim’s is one of Monterey’s iconic seafood spots, but not many people know about the peaceful view. And because the only Monterey hotel room you can afford has a window facing a parking lot, this is a much better place for a clam chowder-filled family dinner that would fit right into a coastal lifestyle magazine.
MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company
$$ | (831) 264-7013 | WEBSITE
This classic Monterey spot serves the kind of Italian authenticity you thought only existed in your head and old family recipe books – and is available for families, casual dining, and lively evenings with live music.
Abalonetti Bar and Grill
$$ | (831) 373-1851 | WEBSITE
The prime location of this Italian restaurant on the Monterey waterfront makes it a great option for large groups. There are two separate dining areas to choose from, including the main dining room with its great view and a larger outdoor patio. Full buyouts are also available.
Pizza Factory Monterey
$ | (831) 747-1028 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a family-friendly spot with great pizza, you’ll appreciate Pizza Factory Monterey. This welcoming restaurant in Monterey offers a menu of delicious pizzas, fresh salads, and quality ingredients. The inviting space seats groups comfortably, the ample parking makes it convenient, and the friendly owners ensure a relaxing atmosphere.
Louie Linguini’s
$$ | (831) 648-8500 | WEBSITE
For the first time since we’ve been here at least, the classic Monterey Italian spot now offers a stunning patio you can enjoy year-round. There’s a cozy section which can hold up to four, as well as a grander dining area complete with panoramic views of the bay that seats up to 40.
Rockfish Harbor Grill
$$ | (831) 324-4375 | WEBSITE
Rockfish Harbor Grill is a harborfront destination that truly delivers on multiple fronts, and now we can add large group accommodations to that list. This Monterey restaurant has a welcoming atmosphere with beautiful pier views, and also offers family gatherings for parties of up to 35, making it a great spot for special occasions.
Café Fina
$$ | (831) 372-5200 | WEBSITE
Seafood lovers and sunset chasers, this one’s for you. This authentic Italian restaurant on the Monterey wharf offers beautiful water views at sunset, making it a perfect spot for a relaxing lunch or dinner. The menu features phenomenal dishes like the Crab Cakes Appetizer, fresh clam pasta, and Pasta Gianni—all well-seasoned and cooked to perfection. The prosciutto arugula pizza is absolute perfection, and the roasted garlic and artichoke are phenomenal, as was the peach cobbler.
The service was absolutely outstanding, with the waitress making amazing recommendations for a phenomenal meal. Locals appreciate the authentic cuisine and VIP treatment. It’s the best place on the wharf.
Old Fishermen’s Grotto
$$ | (831) 375-4604 | WEBSITE
There are a few options at this classic Italian restaurant on Monterey’s waterfront—a window seat accompanied by the sights of sea lions swimming in the bay (according to their menu), a table with a beautiful view of the sunset, and an upstairs area filled with the sounds of the ocean and dimly lit decor.
Paluca Trattoria
$$ | (831) 373-5559 | WEBSITE
Paluca Trattoria might be perched along Monterey Bay, but there’s nowhere else on the coast serving the classic Italian comfort food you’ll find here. As for the setting, the sun-drenched trattoria with a cozy patio area fits 50 people and offers main courses around $24-$32 on weekdays, or $28-$38 on weekends.
Osteria Al Mare
$$ | (831) 920-2833 | WEBSITE
It’s been a staple since its opening, but Osteria Al Mare remains one of Monterey’s toughest reservations—so if you’re hoping to snag a balcony table with that beautiful water view, better book well ahead. The good news? This authentic Italian spot’s outdoor seating with heaters can accommodate a decent-sized group, all of whom will undoubtedly appreciate your foresight in securing a spot at this perpetually busy gem.
Cibo
$$ | (831) 649-8151 | WEBSITE
This vibrant Italian spot in Monterey has a lively bar area with blue LED floor strips and a clientele heavy on happy hour regulars, so if you’d like more of the romantic atmosphere and none of the midweek bustle, book a table in the dimly lit dining area. The patio can fit parties of up to 20 people seated, and if money is no object, there’s a private corner near the jazz performers with full bar service, too.
