The Queens neighborhood of Astoria is world-renowned for its vibrant culinary scene—from authentic Greek tavernas to trendy cocktail bars. And we have the generations of immigrant families who brought their recipes and traditions here, starting in the early 20th century, to thank for that. The stretch along 30th Avenue, which now serves as the unofficial dining corridor, is where you’ll find many of the area’s pizzerias, and is a great spot to convene any night of the week for a perfect slice.
Rosario’s
$$ | (718) 728-2920 | WEBSITE
Rosario’s, like the other pizza spots in this guide, is part of the 16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Astoria, which extends from Ditmars to Broadway with stops in Steinway and Astoria Park. Family owned and operated, Rosario’s is a dough to slice pizzeria that makes everything under one roof. Their standout item is ‘The Famous One’ Sandwich, and the food is made with mozzarella crafted fresh in-house, adding a special touch.
Stop by the deli counter on weekdays and weekends, or call ahead for takeout and enjoy a slice or full Italian dinner.
Milkflower
$$ | (718) 204-1300 | WEBSITE
Milkflower bakes all of its pizzas in a wood-fired oven and is perfect for watching the kitchen work its magic. Just be sure to grab a seat at the counter or at one of the rustic tables inside before it gets too crowded on weekends. The creative pizzas, like the ricotta made with fresh cheese, herbs, and a beautiful char are definitely the highlight—the experience here is really best for savoring each slice rather than rushing through a meal.
Papa Johns Pizza
$$ | (718) 728-7272 | WEBSITE
Not only does Papa John’s Pizza have the best late-night option in Astoria—open until the wee hours for those post-midnight cravings—but pretty much every 10-inch pie is worth customizing. Get your order in by 11:30pm to ensure the manager can personally oversee your large group request, and then dive into your create-your-own pizza with decent toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms.
On any given evening, you’ll encounter a mix of solo diners and late-night regulars grabbing their reasonably priced $20 meal, so if you’re looking for a satisfying bite without breaking the bank, you might want to check Papa John’s Pizza.
Sophistian Pizzeria Restaurant
$ | (917) 456-1025 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in the heart of Astoria, Sophistian Pizzeria Restaurant is a vibrant new destination that goes far beyond its name. Serving up satisfying meals inspired by classic American comfort food, the menu features both timeless staples and creative twists like the popular Mexican pizza and seafood pasta. The wine bar offers a selection of approachable pours perfect for pairing with any dish.
Settle in at the cozy indoor tables or grab a seat at the bustling counter, where the welcoming atmosphere makes every visit feel like a neighborhood gathering. Be sure to arrive early or call ahead, as this spot draws a steady crowd, especially for their praised brunch and breakfast sandwiches.
Tufino Pizzeria
$$ | (718) 278-4800 | WEBSITE
You’ll quickly feel at home at Tufino Pizzeria, whether you’re chatting with the friendly staff or sharing recommendations with fellow diners at the next table. The menu celebrates authentic Italian flavors with creative twists, featuring standout dishes like wood-fired octopus, Robiola pizza, and the surprisingly delicious Truffle Burretta Burger with prosciutto.
This spot is a bit tucked away in Astoria—it’s not on the main drag—but the vibrant, casual atmosphere makes it worth seeking out, especially if you grab a seat near the open kitchen to watch the chefs work. You might even catch a birthday celebration in full swing, with groups enjoying frozen cocktails and gluten-free zeppoles with Nutella. Just another evening at Tufino.
Basil Brick Oven Pizza
$$ | (718) 204-1205 | WEBSITE
Basil Brick Oven Pizza opened in the heart of Astoria, and is home to some of the neighborhood’s best Italian cuisine. But you don’t need a special occasion to come here—there are classic pizzas and fresh pasta dishes on the menu. When you’re craving something authentic, they have a brick oven that gives every pie that perfect char. You can order and enjoy your meal in the quiet, intimate dining room, or take it home for a cozy night in.
Two standouts are the Margherita and prosciutto arugula pizzas, although everything we’ve tried has been delicious.
Chubby Burgers Chicken & Pizza
$ | (718) 932-8855 | WEBSITE
Chubby Burgers Chicken & Pizza has been serving Astoria for years, and it’s perfect when you’re looking to walk in and get some of the best fried chicken in town for under $15. Go for the halal chicken dishes, which are crispy and flavorful, or the fresh burgers with good fries. On busier evenings, you should grab a seat near the window and watch the neighborhood buzz.
Because this place is tucked into an unassuming storefront, it almost feels like a hidden gem among locals, with the bonus of clean surroundings and friendly service.
Brother’s Pizzeria
$ | (718) 777-1111 | WEBSITE
With its convenient Astoria location offering street parking and nearby bus access, Brother’s Pizzeria is a local Balkan restaurant that’s carved out a reputation for generous portions and moderate prices. It’s more than just a pizzeria, though. It’s a destination for those craving Eastern European comfort foods and grilled specialties. Dig into a plate of roasted lamb or veal or warm up with a hearty bowl of Goulash.
Their efficient service ensures fresh food arrives quickly, while the clean, friendly atmosphere makes you feel right at home. The outdoor seating provides a pleasant option, and wheelchair accessibility means everyone can enjoy this neighborhood gem.
Rizzo’s Pizza
$ | (718) 721-9862 | WEBSITE
Rizzo’s Pizza is an Astoria institution with constant lines of people waiting for authentic New York slices. The wait is worth it though—the classic pies, like the Verdura with its fresh vegetables and vegan cheese option, are fantastic. It’s in a cozy storefront on a bustling Astoria street that goes hard on the old-school pizza parlor vibe, with checkered tablecloths and vintage photos spread throughout the restaurant.
Don’t skip ordering directly from their website to take advantage of the rewards program.
Sotto la Luna
$$ | (631) 380-3569 | WEBSITE
Sotto la Luna should be your first stop for pizza. With authentic Italian dishes like the crowd-favorite Bufala pizza and the cacio e pepe prepared tableside in a cheese wheel, it’s always difficult to choose between options. Another highlight is the generous portions at reasonable prices, making it a great choice for dining in or ordering delivery.
Sotto la Luna is by no means a secret—the warm, inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for date nights or gatherings—so it’s a good spot to enjoy that won’t cost you more than $25. If you decide to eat here, though, you’ll find a room with an open kitchen where chefs prepare meals with care, and exceptionally welcoming staff like Gianluca creating memorable experiences.
Nonnas 1977
$ | (718) 606-0060 | WEBSITE
Stepping into Nonnas 1977 feels like you’ve entered a rock-and-roll pizzeria that’s also an Italian kitchen with house-made dough, sauce, and mozzarella. It’s nestled near Astoria Park and serves up authentic pizza, heroes, and pasta, although we’re quite partial to the Angie slice with artichoke cooked to perfection and creamy ricotta. Choose from classic pies or try one of Nonnas’ specialties, like the bomb parm or chicken parm hero, with many options available gluten-free or vegan.
The cozy interior features rock memorabilia on the walls and our favorite spot to catch live jazz on Wednesdays or rock on weekends. An added bonus: it’s perfect for a romantic pizza date.
S & S Calabro Pizzeria
$ | (718) 278-5262 | WEBSITE
S & S Calabro Pizzeria is the perfect spot to grab a quick slice or whole pie before your next Queens adventure. While there are a few cozy tables inside with that classic ‘Mom and Pop’ shop vibe, it’s best to order your pizza to go. Their pies are all excellent, but the classic cheese pizza, which features that delicious sauce and quality fresh cheese, is the best thing on the menu.
It’s also super close to Astoria Park, where you can bring your hot and fresh pizza to enjoy with a view for a truly authentic New York experience.
Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria
$$ | (718) 407-2497 | WEBSITE
If you’ve spent the day exploring Astoria and find yourself craving something truly satisfying, head straight to Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria. While you can certainly enjoy the lively atmosphere inside, it’s also a perfect spot for a quick takeout slice or a whole pie to go—especially if you’re in the mood for their standout vodkaroni or the must-try clam pie.
The variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni to unique combinations, might leave you a little indecisive, but our top pick is the White Magic slice, a flavorful masterpiece that keeps us coming back. Their homemade brownies, served warm and rich, are the ideal sweet finish to any meal.
ASAP Pizza Spot & Restaurant
$ | (347) 848-0085 | WEBSITE
If you’re craving authentic New York pizza, head straight to ASAP Pizza Spot & Restaurant in Astoria. This cozy neighborhood spot is tucked away on a bustling street, where the aroma of baking dough greets you before you even walk through the door. To say this place is welcoming would be an understatement. As you step inside, you’ll notice the simple counter setup and the open kitchen where Mr.
Nick works his magic, with each pizza coming out of the oven perfectly blistered (don’t be surprised if he offers you complimentary fried dough while you wait). The menu focuses on classic pies made with fresh ingredients, like the white pizza with creamy ricotta or the margherita with that perfect oil-to-cheese ratio. On busy evenings, there’s often a steady stream of regulars picking up orders, where you can chat with the owner and hear about his latest accommodating gesture for a customer.
Bartolino’s – Fine Italian Cuisine
$$ | (718) 278-9839 | WEBSITE
Bartolino’s – Fine Italian Cuisine is one of Astoria’s finest Italian spots, and the cozy Sicilian-inspired space centered around warm lighting and rustic décor makes it ideal for a family dinner or gathering with friends. Order the recommended pasta dish (preferably with an aperol spritz) and watch as a perfectly prepared plate with Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, and garlic in a white wine sauce arrives tableside.
Come during dinner service and try the old fashioned, made with premium whiskey, bitters, and a hint of citrus. Be sure to save room for dessert—their amazing baked clams, served with lemon and herbs, are fantastic.
Mela Pizza
$ | (718) 777-5533 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in the heart of Astoria, Mela Pizza is a neighborhood staple that serves up delicious slices, especially late into the night. The menu features classic pizzas, a popular chicken sandwich, and pasta bolognese, but we usually go for the traditional pizza with a sprinkle of garlic or the complimentary garlic knots. Beyond the food, Mela Pizza has a pleasant, clean atmosphere with friendly, attentive staff, including the owner.
You’ll find many Astoria locals here, and it’s best used for a quick, affordable bite with great service.
