If you think about it, the pigeons of Baltimore’s Inner Harbor are probably going to get pretty confused come 2026. What happened? When did the humans become so obsessed with pizza? Is that the guy from the new Netflix food documentary?
The Dive
$$ | (667) 309-7499 | WEBSITE
Forget that boring chain pizza joint and head to The Dive instead. This quirky spot in Baltimore is serving everything from Dorito pizza to fried eggplant in a space that feels like a retro party. There’s a lot of creative dishes to choose from but our strategy would be to get the cheesesteak sub, the fried pickles, plenty of pizza with that freshly-baked crust, and of course, lots of sausage and eggplant pizza—though you might want to add a pinch of salt.
Vinny’s Cafe
$ | (410) 633-7709 | WEBSITE
Pizza in Baltimore, baby. Alright yes, you might have to circle the block a few times looking for parking since the lot’s on the smaller side, but that’s the trade-off every time you crave authentic Italian in a family-owned spot that’s been rocking for over two decades. Get involved with their must-try 30″ pizza—it’s massive, fresh, and totally worth the slightly higher price tag.
If you’re looking to go big for a game day or happy hour—and we mean big—they’ve also got killer dishes in rose cream sauce, seafood pasta specials, and a comprehensive menu with everything from Chicken Broccoli to gnocchi. The newly remodeled dining room is stunning, though the high arched ceilings can get a bit loud, adding to that lively, homey vibe. Don’t miss out on Vinny’s, a community favorite that never disappoints.
Micky’s Joint
$ | (443) 835-1081 | WEBSITE
Technically your favourite thing about pizza is the crust. Honestly, same. But if you live in or around Baltimore your second favourite thing should be Micky’s Joint. This neighbourhood pizza spot is doing thin-crust pies with creative toppings for under twenty bucks as well as other tasty dishes. Expect classic album cover menus, locally made Octoberfest beer, Sunday acoustic music, and countless slices of awesome pizza.
Pub Dog Pizza & Drafthouse
$ | (410) 727-6077 | WEBSITE
Ever shared a perfect pizza with some friends at a cozy tavern? We have. It’s fantastic. It’s also how we know that it’s impossible to get that thin, fluffy crust out of your mind. Still, we regret nothing and neither will you if you order one of the signature pizzas like the Cajun Dog or Veggie Dog. A whole pie with fresh ingredients and that praised beer on tap for around $20? Don’t mind if we do. Going big?
There’s the Wing Dog too, with toppings that feel like they could rearrange your taste buds.
Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar
$$ | (443) 438-7562 | WEBSITE
Sure, there was a time when ‘pizza night’ meant greasy cardboard from a chain joint, but since then you’ve been through a pandemic and an entire series of cooking shows. You’ve grown. Now, you want that full authentic, crust and topping experience. All-round solid pizzeria and bar Angeli’s is doing everything you need for a proper pizza meal, including the Della Carne pizza, Angeli’s Pick pizza, and drinks. Just make sure you don’t skip their trivia nights on Thursdays.
Silver Queen Cafe
$$ | (443) 345-2020 | WEBSITE
Family-friendly hang? Absolutely nailed it, folks. That’s what you’ll declare after trying the Silver Queen Cafe’s perfectly curated seasonal menu. It features – take note – pickle brined chicken sandwiches, crab dip appetizers, butterfly pea flower infused tequila cocktails, and homemade ketchup that’s one of the tastiest things ever. They’re welcoming to all and, most importantly, they’re offering cozy, intimate atmosphere despite the limited seating.
Vito’s Pizza
$ | (410) 323-8486 | WEBSITE
This Towson pizza joint is serving The Cheeseburger Sub, which might sound like a throwback, but it’s actually their signature sandwich. We’re talking crispy crust pizza, and a selection of New York-style slices. If you’re someone who likes your meal with a side of comfort, there’s also chicken parmigiana that includes pasta, or white pizzas that involve fresh toppings and plenty of cheese. They’re accommodating dietary restrictions and there are vegetarian options available too.
Mario’s Original Pizza & Pasta
$ | (410) 435-9500 | WEBSITE
Mario’s Original Pizza & Pasta is serving up crispy crusts, fresh pasta, and some other delicious things that don’t start with P. We’re very into their classic pepperoni pizza, but it’s their customizable cheesesteak sub that has ‘game day’ written all over it. It comes hot and perfectly assembled, with melted cheese, fresh toppings, and all the flavor you crave, but there’s also a fresh Italian cold cut option and crispy onion rings to get involved in too.
Pie in the Sky
$ | (410) 522-3222 | WEBSITE
After much deliberation we’ve decided that pizza is just the sandwich’s more sophisticated sibling and honestly we’d take a floppy slice over artisanal bread any day. Thanks to Pie in the Sky you can still bring some of that restaurant-quality energy to your takeout with their Fells’ pie. It includes everything you need for the perfect sausage and sauce situation, including fresh dough and Old Bay wings. Just bring a cold drink and maybe some napkins. Because, Baltimore pizza.
TinyBrickOven
$ | (443) 627-8277 | WEBSITE
TinyBrickOven is a pizza shop that knows how to do truly inspiring things to a crust. No, we’re not talking your bog-standard delivery pizza, we’re talking New York-style with that perfect thin, crispy foundation, just the right cheese pull, and a chew that makes you close your eyes. Now you can get their excellent offerings with both vegan and beef pepperoni toppings, served up in their cozy, simple space that’s all about big taste.
Yes, you’ll have to squeeze into a small table and maybe share a smile with a stranger, but if you managed to navigate Baltimore’s one-way streets on a Saturday night, you can handle this. The owner, Will, greets you with a genuine warmth that feels like the place’s secret sauce, and that Pay-It-Forward program adds a sprinkle of community spirit that’s as welcome as the gelato for dessert.
It’s the kind of spot where every pizza feels made with care, and you’ll leave already plotting your return.
Tony + Benny’s
$ | (410) 684-5273 | WEBSITE
It is physically impossible to stop eating Tony + Benny’s garlic knots. If you think we’re joking you should see how many baskets of these warm, buttery delights we go through every single visit. Tony + Benny’s is one of Baltimore’s best pizza spots near the airport and their classic Italian-American fare is not only wildly tasty but super affordable.
Alongside your very necessary order of garlic knots, grab a slice of their outstanding pizza with that perfect crust and sauce, a fresh salad, and their excellent wings.
HomeSlyce – JHU
$ | (443) 315-4046 | WEBSITE
‘What’s up, what’s up, what’s up! HomeSlyce JHU 2026, can I get a ‘yeah yeah’ from the pizza lovers in the house!’ – you to the three students eyeing your last slice of Strongman Meat Lovers. Granted there’s a limit on the amount of excitement you can have sitting in a cozy brick booth wishing you were at a pizza party, but the fun little personal slyces from HomeSlyce will definitely help lift the mood.
Throw in a couple of their craft beers from the well-curated selection and you’re onto a winner.
Underground Pizza Baltimore
$ | (443) 347-6190 | WEBSITE
You know when you were a kid and your dad told you that the other families looked at you weird because they were jealous, but retrospectively it was because you continued to order the same plain cheese pizza long into adulthood? All been there, haven’t we. Well, in the case of people staring when you crack out Detroit-style deep dish in Baltimore we would like to confirm that they 100% are looking because they’re jealous.
Order the must-try Trifecta pizza from go-to pizza specialists Underground Pizza Baltimore and just remember to bring your appetite. Plus, you just know that those crab dip + rangoon toppings would approve.
Isabella’s Brick Oven
$ | (410) 962-8888 | WEBSITE
The last time you had truly authentic Italian pizza you were on vacation in Naples. But fast forward to 2026, and that authentic experience is right here in Baltimore. Isabella’s Brick Oven is delivering perfectly charred crusts, fresh ingredients, and those amazing cannoli’s from their cozy little shop. Grab a San Pelligrino, that friend who appreciates good cheese blends, and a couple of their pepperoni slices if a whole pizza isn’t your thing.
Angeli’s Pizzeria
$ | (410) 347-7610 | WEBSITE
Two words. Pizza slice. That’s right, we see your standard pepperoni pie and we raise you a super tasty, customizable slice with fresh bruschetta topped with ricotta. Not only is everything that Angeli’s Pizzeria serves incredibly welcoming – shoutout to their lunch special that’s both more personable and has more warmth than a family dinner – they’re also conveniently located within walking distance to Camden Yards.
We’ve got our eye on the side salad that’s fresh and delicious, but if you’re after something laid-back they’ve also got that inviting atmosphere and wheelchair accessibility. Organizing a game day gathering? Angeli’s has got you covered with pizza by the slice and that family feeling too.
The Owl Bar
$$ | (410) 347-0888 | WEBSITE
We adore anything that whispers ‘historic charm’. It makes us feel sophisticated and like we might have stepped into a 1920s novel. Someone wonderfully insightful once remarked that ‘the duck fat fries at The Owl Bar are some of the best bar snacks, hands down’. Yes, that someone was us, but it’s absolutely true. Elevate your evening with their exceptional wings, or indulge fully in their crab omelette with great potatoes. Browse their extensive menu for even more classic American options.
