Pizza in Easton runs the gamut from classic corner-slice joints to wood-fired Neapolitan temples. For a town of our stature, we’re punching well above our weight. Whether you’re after a quick $3 slice or a $30 artisanal pie, this guide has you covered. Let’s narrow down your perfect pizza pilgrimage.
Forks Pizza & grill
$ | (610) 258-4252 | WEBSITE
Forks Pizza & Grill is a solid, dependable, and affordable pizza spot, right in the heart of Easton. Which is why it’s almost always full of families and pizza lovers, and why there’s almost always a small, manageable wait to get a table during peak hours. Forks Pizza & Grill is nothing fancy, but it’s a great option for a casual weeknight dinner with pretty high-quality food.
One of the specialties is the cheese steak that’s considered the best in the area, but our favorite thing to order is the Italian Stromboli, the calzone-like dish stuffed with a generous mix of fillings.
Frank’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza
$ | (610) 252-0252 | WEBSITE
From the team behind some of Easton’s most reliable Italian spots, Frank’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza serves thin-crust pies, antipasto platters, and lunch specials out of a welcoming storefront on Main Street. Despite the straightforward name, it’s not really priced like a bare-bones pizza joint, and the atmosphere is far too comfortable to indicate otherwise. But you’re not here for a rushed takeout meal—you’re here for family dinners and casual gatherings where frozen pizza just won’t cut it.
The pizza is generously topped and leans classic in its preparation—fresh dough, balanced sauce, with quality ingredients. It doesn’t compete with Philadelphia’s fancy Neapolitan pizzerias, but at least dinner won’t set you back $30 a person.
Pino’s Pizzeria
$ | (610) 253-2944 | WEBSITE
Pino’s Pizzeria is often considered one of the most authentic pizza joints in Easton, with prices that show they’re clearly focused on value. It’s a place to dress down a little and feel like family as you watch your pie get prepared in a space that’s basically a time capsule of the glory days, with a dough master that looks like he could have just stepped out of any classic Italian kitchen. There are two main offerings here that stay consistent regardless of when you visit.
Most days it’s the Neapolitan pies—a mix of classic toppings and perfect crust—but there’s also the catering option for parties, and a selection of wings that shouldn’t be missed. All of them deliver that taste of the old days served up just right, with quality and quantity that generally play with both tradition and heart.
Vinny V’s Pizza
$ | (610) 253-5533 | WEBSITE
Just a short drive from downtown Easton, Vinny V’s Pizza offers a pretty solid lineup of pies and appetizers, in addition to a full menu of hearty Italian-American classics to round out your meal (if you really want a standout, order the leopard pizza, where a perfectly charred crust arrives topped with bubbling cheese and savory toppings). Much like at the best NY-style spots, the slices here are on the generous end.
But the pizza options are satisfying, and each comes loaded with a hearty set of toppings. That means you can expect everything from more classic pepperoni and cheese to the hefty 16″ Sicilian German pizza with sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
Quality Pizza
$ | (610) 252-1628 | WEBSITE
Perhaps best known for the A1 pizza (that remains a customer favorite, with generous portions), Quality Pizza is a reliable and homestyle pizza restaurant in Easton. The menu is straightforward, spanning from LG plain pizzas to mozzarella sticks. Also on the menu are their specials—none of it will blow your mind, but it’s all carefully-prepared, consistent, and dependable.
The restaurant is kid-friendly with patient employees, so be prepared for a family-friendly atmosphere during peak hours, but we really like to eat in the nice and calm dining area when it’s available.
Sicily’s Pizza II
$ | (610) 559-7995 | WEBSITE
Despite Sicily’s Pizza II being about 4,500 miles away from Sicily, this pizza spot and Italian restaurant in Forks Township will make you feel like you’re at a cozy trattoria on a bustling street in Italy, complete with checkered tablecloths lining the dining area and an open kitchen window where you can watch pizzas bubble and pasta get tossed. The rigatoni ala vodka here is excellent, with al dente pasta and a rich, creamy sauce, most of which was simmering in a pot just a few hours ago.
Sicily’s II is where we go for the perfect balance of atmosphere and great food, at prices that feel just right for a casual Friday night.
Antonio’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream
$ | (610) 250-9811 | WEBSITE
Finding a table at one of Easton’s top pizza joints can be a challenge on weekends, but none is quite as reliably busy as Antonio’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream, a family-friendly spot that often has a line out the door during peak hours. It’s a welcoming space, with an interior that feels a bit like the dining room of an Italian grandmother who spent some time picking up modern restaurant tips from a neighborhood diner, and a straightforward counter with simple seating.
Expect classic pizza options like the popular white pizza and the excellent margherita, along with homemade favorites like stuffed shells and fresh riceballs. This is pizza in its most satisfying form—topped with nothing but quality ingredients and care—and sets the standard in Easton for family-friendly Italian dining.
Antonio’s Pizzeria
$ | (610) 253-9977 | WEBSITE
Antonio’s Pizzeria serves pizza that’s about as classic as it gets, with most pies topped in just tomato sauce, mozzarella, and the occasional sprinkle of oregano or fresh basil. The crust might be a little too thick in spots, but it’s baked well and makes for a welcome foundation to the generous slices of high-quality toppings piled on both ends. If you’re not much of a pizza expert, just order one of the “specialty pizzas” and let the kitchen make the hard choices.
Despite being located in a simple, no-frills space in Easton, Antonio’s is remarkably cozy—complete with checkered tablecloths, shelves full of Italian memorabilia, and hanging light fixtures made from repurposed wine bottles.
MOD Pizza
$ | (484) 935-0006 | WEBSITE
MOD Pizza is a casual pan pizza spot in Easton with a spacious dining area that holds plenty of large tables. It’s from the team behind the MOD Pizza chain—a concept we like very much—and as a result, it feels like an even more family-friendly version of its other locations.
It’s located in a standalone building with ample parking, meaning you can grab items from the made-to-order counter for a satisfying meal consisting of a soft drink from the fountain, fresh salads from the toppings bar, and as many customizable pizzas as you can comfortably handle from MOD Pizza.
Colonial Pizza & Spaghetti House
$ | (610) 252-3033 | WEBSITE
You can’t talk about pizza in Easton without Colonial Pizza & Spaghetti House’s name entering the conversation. The team behind this pizza and Italian restaurant have built a local favorite spanning decades, but it all started right here in a cozy renovated space with that welcoming atmosphere.
Colonial Pizza has a core pizza menu with classic pies like pepperoni or cheese, but the really good stuff is on their specialty section—named after the generous toppings and calzone fillings that make the experience memorable. The portions here tend to be on the generous side, like well-stuffed calzones that haven’t held back yet. They also have that cool, laid-back vibe downstairs, with that old-school charm giving off a real hometown feel.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (610) 253-4200 | WEBSITE
Unlike other pizza chains on this list, this Papa John’s location feels like a neighborhood staple. Every time you order, you’ll get exactly what you asked for, with no mix-ups on pick-up or delivery. All of the pizzas, including the Meats Lover’s, come out consistently flavorful and perfectly baked. And despite being a fast-food operation, the service never feels rushed or impersonal. Place an order for a quick dinner, but if you want the full experience, you’ll need to swing by for pick-up.
They’ll even help carry your food to the car, which makes it feel like a personal touch—it’s especially fitting since the staff is so genuinely friendly and down-to-earth.
Franks Pizza & Italian Restaurant
$ | (610) 252-7002 | WEBSITE
This unassuming Palmer Twp spot should be the poster child for pizzerias that capture authentic NY cuisine. Pizza is the focal point here—with most pies boasting some level of crispiness, chewiness, or probably magic to bring out different textures and flavors—and the toppings are accents instead of the overloaded grease bombs you might find somewhere like a chain joint.
The other dishes served alongside the main attraction are where things shine a little beyond the classic pizza format, adding Italian flavors without turning the meal into some forced menu that relies on gimmicks. There are no hidden fees at the end and no extra charges—you won’t need them anyway.
Casa di Franco Pizzeria
$ | (610) 258-3268 | WEBSITE
About half of Casa di Franco’s menu is made up of classic pizzeria fare, but our favorite way to visit is for a quick lunch stop during a busy day running errands in Easton. Unlike other spots that like to pride themselves on how artisanal their ingredients are, Casa di Franco instead focuses on consistently delicious comfort food, which packs it full of satisfying, familiar flavors and excellent value.
While most of the pizza leans into traditional toppings, there are a few that incorporate their Italian-American influence, like the Cheesesteak Stromboli with perfect texture and flavor.
picasso pizza II
$ | (610) 923-7795 | WEBSITE
Picasso Pizza II technically falls under Easton’s pizza scene, but it deserves a spot on any local pizza short list. The real-time cooking style means you’ll usually see a steady stream of orders, with waits stretching past 20 minutes during peak hours. The payoff is a Sicilian pizza that goes toe to toe with many of Pennsylvania’s top pies, at neighborhood prices.
Expect fresh, generously topped slices, perfectly balanced sauce, and careful attention to every detail (sometimes with a bonus garlic knot or two if you’re dining in).
Amore Pizzería
$ | (610) 438-1309 | WEBSITE
Amore Pizzería is one of the only spots in Easton dedicated to thin-crust pizza, so both casual fans of classic pies and Philly transplants seeking a suitable substitute for the city’s famous slices can find common ground at this convenient local favorite. The crust is thin and flavorful, the toppings are generous and fresh, and the cheese steaks are praised for their hearty portions.
You can pick from a handful of suggested combinations—we like the classic pepperoni—or go a la carte with options like chicken wraps. If you’re still hungry, finish off your meal with a BYOB beverage in the clean, dimly lit dining area where you can watch the kitchen at work.
My New Place Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
$ | (610) 253-3387 | WEBSITE
My New Place Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant has been around for years, and it’s always buzzing, full of regulars who know the secret that some of Easton’s best pizza can be found here. There are plenty of crowd-pleasing dishes that are actually pretty great, despite having straightforward names like Meat Lovers pizza, creamy Vodka penne, crisp onion rings, and fresh Caesar salad.
But the best thing to do here is order anything and everything off the menu, from the perfectly cooked crusts with runny cheese and generous toppings to the tasty fries and pierogies that come out fast and hot.
