Fayetteville is a college town through and through, home to the Razorbacks on any given Saturday, and a favorite destination for food lovers and chefs alike. So it’s no surprise the city boasts a thriving pizza scene. That said, it can be hard to know where to find the perfect slice among the countless options—chain deliveries and frozen pies aside. If you don’t want to wander aimlessly through a forest of menus, start with these spots.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (479) 582-5533 | WEBSITE
Pizza lovers or families with dietary needs should head straight to Papa Murphy’s. The take-and-bake spot is pretty much busy from the moment it opens. And with dairy-free cheese this good, it’s easy to see why. Fayetteville locals come by to fill their kitchens with gourmet vegetarian pizza so delicious you’ll be slicing into it on the spot. Of the options, the garlic cream sauce creation, loaded with fresh toppings, is a delight. But so too are the garlic bread and pinwheels.
Given the phenomenal staff with excellent teamwork, it’s a lovely spot for a weekly pizza night.
Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
$ | (479) 521-1001 | WEBSITE
Mellow Mushroom is the pizza joint to head to in Fayetteville. It’s nestled in the heart of town and you want to order confidently. Owners of popular pizza spots are a particular type: laid-back on the outside but with the discerning eye of a pizza purist when it comes to perfect crusts. The Holy Shiitake pizza (mushrooms, creamy sauce, no skimping) is essential. As are the fresh salads. We can never resist a glass of that house-made lemonade either. Grab a seat in the cozy dining room.
Smokin’ Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom
$ | (479) 480-8900 | WEBSITE
Smokin’ Oak might not have a rustic countryside setting but its wood-fired pizza is good enough for you to want to take refuge from any ordinary pizza joints with a taste for something special. The welcoming spot under an upscale apartment complex makes a delicious menu of things like Alfredo pizza, Italian Stallion, and plenty of options for kids. You won’t be pining for anything else.
It’s very easy to fall for this place, whether you stop in for Tuesday night trivia with a great host, or come for a relaxed evening sharing board games and puzzles with friends while enjoying consistently fresh and fast service.
Mojo’s Pints & Pies East Fayetteville
$ | (479) 316-7771 | WEBSITE
A slice of sports bar perfection in Fayetteville, Mojo’s seduces with the sound of cheers erupting, a pizza menu scrawled on chalkboards like game-day plays, and flickering TVs come evening. The hangout is a lively and vibrant space which suits bringing friends you want to, well, get loud and celebratory with. Sitting on the patio seating, which faces a bustling street, breaks the immersion a little.
Instead, head to the indoor bar area—the light will bounce off your pint glass and glistening pepperoni pizza, and make you feel like your best fan self.
Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar
$ | (479) 301-2815 | WEBSITE
Fayetteville isn’t a pizza capital but it does have a growing roster of solid, family-friendly pizzerias—and Marley’s is one of them. The pizzeria and bar has a consistently excellent menu and an exceedingly good-natured feel to it, from the kind and friendly staff, to the cozy atmosphere inside, to dishes like the Caesar salad pizza for lunch. It bills itself as a place to settle in, whether for a solo personal pizza at the bar or for a beer post-dinner, and it really does feel like that.
You’ll find livelier types chatting and drinking at night, while groups of friends gather at the wooden tables for things like Chicken Alfredo Pizza and Cheese Bread.
Newk’s Eatery
$$ | (479) 856-6395 | WEBSITE
Newk’s Eatery, a pizza spot in Fayetteville, a little further down from the university district, is somewhere you need to check out. The menu at the revamped American eatery changes depending on the season, but it’s bound to be pretty satisfying. Pasta salad with bacon and ranch, cauliflower crust pizza, and consistently good salads gives you a general gist. They also specialise in family-friendly service and the changing coloring sheets for kids are great.
Jimmy’s Pizza
$ | (479) 527-6701 | WEBSITE
Jimmy’s Pizza is a reliable local spot where you’re just as likely to grab a quick delivery order as you are to sit down for a satisfying, customizable pie. Right in the heart of Fayetteville, this is a top choice for a casual weeknight dinner. We particularly like the Hog Wild pizza with extra sauce if we’re feeling adventurous.
The Hot Chick can be a little spicy but if you’re into bold flavors, then settle into one of the cozy booths inside, dig into a cheesy breadstick on the side, and enjoy the efficient, friendly service.
Geraldi’s
$ | (479) 575-0556 | WEBSITE
A meal at Geraldi’s feels like the embodiment of all your Italian family dinner fantasies, right in Fayetteville. This cozy Italian spot is a warm, bustling dining room of a restaurant from Tuesday to Sunday evenings (it’s closed on Mondays). Garlic bread and jars of craft soda sit on the tables around you, and bowls of creamy pesto spaghetti with meatballs in front.
Its consistent menu is as irresistible as the lively, amiable atmosphere—and spicy chicken alfredo or light-as-a-feather slabs of homemade tiramisu will live long in the memory. Bear in mind this place only has just over a dozen tables, so arriving early is wise.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (479) 445-6555 | WEBSITE
Domino’s Pizza is the go-to spot for a quick and satisfying slice. It’s conveniently located, always ready for a speedy pickup, and, most importantly, serves up reliably tasty pizza. The Extravaganza, loaded with toppings, is a solid choice, and the Marble Cookie Brownies are a sweet treat that never disappoints. And it’s all done efficiently. The signature pizza features a hearty mix of meats and veggies—baked until bubbly—plus a layer of melted cheese and robust sauce.
The occasional inconsistency combines with a generally helpful staff to create a familiar, if sometimes uneven, experience.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (479) 521-5553 | WEBSITE
This pizza joint may as well be called Follow The Smile given how many satisfied-looking families and regulars (in that order) leave its unassuming storefront with a hot box or two in hand. The standout of this straightforward takeout spot is the freshly made dough. The dough is stretched and topped with quality ingredients right there, to create a gloriously even, flavorful pie with a perfectly cooked crust.
Options include the crustless pizza for dietary needs, but there’s regular pepperoni and cheese coming out of the ovens too, with plenty of garlic bread and classic combo choices. The service is consistently friendly and efficient for everyone too.
Cicis Pizza
$ | (479) 582-9292 | WEBSITE
Nothing is more inevitable than grabbing a slice at a pizza buffet when you’re craving something hot and satisfying. As per any family-friendly spot, Fayetteville has its most-visited pizza joints and also one that’s a little more casual and budget-friendly. You’ll more than likely opt for Cicis Pizza as it’s right there with the all-you-can-eat buffet and the pizza is excellent. Fresh, tasty pies, including the popular Macaroni Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
Plus those behind the counter are some of the friendliest staff around and happy to take your order. If you don’t mind a simple setup with claw machines and a salad bar, there’s Cicis. Some locals say that’s where you should be getting your pizza fix.
Eureka Pizza
$ | (479) 571-2121 | WEBSITE
Two things you should know about Eureka Pizza: it’s always busy and the wait is worth it. So whatever time you go, expect a crowd. The cozy, no-frills space is popular with locals and students, for good reason. Pizzas are given special treatment with fresh ingredients and generous cheese, but pay attention to the supreme. Always aromatic, always loaded, always satisfying. The supreme pizza is a go-to. We’ve had it with extra pepperoni and mushrooms, and classic with sausage and green peppers.
Either way it’s a winner.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (479) 443-7733 | WEBSITE
While not quite fine dining, there is a growing appreciation for family restaurants that deliver genuine fun alongside decent food. Chuck E. Cheese is one of these and, in fact, is the quintessential destination for birthday parties and family outings in Fayetteville. The lively, game-filled space buzzes with energy from the arcade, and a quick lunch can turn into hours of entertainment very easily.
A slice of their surprisingly good pizza combined with the cheerful presence of staff like Party Hostess Lexi and the chance to dance with Chuck E. will set the tone nicely. Watching kids light up while playing games with the option of fixed-time passes instead of tokens, even better.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (479) 444-1999 | WEBSITE
Although they make a delicious pizza and the breadsticks are incredibly satisfying, the food at Papa John’s isn’t even the best thing about it. Before we even tried the non-frozen dough and the better ingredients that went into each pie, we decided this was a spot we would order from again. Inside a clean, welcoming space in Fayetteville, Papa John’s is a warm, reliable place with an excellent focus on quality and service.
Staff members work with great attitude during late hours, the care put into each pizza brings back nostalgic memories of homemade Italian food, and the fast delivery makes it a popular choice for many customers.
Wicked Wood Fired Pizza
$ | (479) 466-8911 | WEBSITE
When you want to have a few slices of pizza sitting at a family table, but not your kitchen table, there’s Wicked Wood Fired Pizza. The main area of this wood-fired pizza spot at Ozark Brewing is set up like a welcoming dining room. The other side of the counter, near the hearth, is a bit more rustic. It’s as comfortable as popping round to a friend’s house, but with better crust, a better seasoning balance, and a perfectly baked pizza that beats the frozen pies they usually serve.
The food is pizza-focused and the toppings vary, but you might see combinations like delicious pepperoni with fresh mozzarella and mushrooms with caramelized onions.
Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe
$ | (479) 966-4656 | WEBSITE
The best time to visit Pickleman’s is during the lunch rush. The gourmet cafe, in Fayetteville, doesn’t get as chaotic as the chain spots and is the ideal place to grab a quick, satisfying meal. But it’s not the only reason to come (especially since most of the time the line isn’t serving ‘wait forever’). The pizza and sandwiches are excellent and straightforward, but not boring. It’s the kind of place that describes their large Italian chopped salad as “very ‘loaded with meat and veggies'”.
The friendly staff and composed service invite returning, especially if you order online for pickup.
Tim’s Pizza
$ | (479) 521-5056 | WEBSITE
Tim’s Pizza is as much a community hub as it is a classic hometown spot. The welcoming pizza joint on its unassuming corner has a variety of pies and salads every day but is probably best-known for its excellent cheese pizza. Regulars and newcomers order ahead for the “Fools Gold” with all its cheesiness, but on weekends the full menu still satisfies the crowd.
A “mini pepperoni & Italian sausage” is loaded with toppings and the beer selection pairs well with watching the friendly staff work the counter. It’s a laid-back, comfortable space where everyone is made to feel at home.
U.S. Pizza Co Fayetteville
$ | (479) 582-4808 | WEBSITE
There are lots of pizza places in Fayetteville, but U.S. Pizza Co is the best. It sits in a busy part of town, but inside there’s a sense of nostalgia. Plates of greasy, crispy pizza and the occasional salad supreme are ferried between tables. They go back to the kitchen empty, every last slice devoured by hungry customers. Glasses of soda are sipped as chatter and attention turns to the fun fact that, by law, we ‘own’ the pizza company. U.S.
Pizza Co is all about excellent pizza, quick lunches, and even longer dinners with friends.
Wood Stone Craft Pizza Uptown
$ | (479) 287-4800 | WEBSITE
There’s a casual, neighborhood vibe to Wood Stone Craft Pizza Uptown that masks some of the creativity happening in this pizza spot. The simple space is bright and airy, with a nice outdoor patio perfect for people-watching. Their margherita and grilled garden pizzas are solid, but the star of the show is the Thai curry pizza. The pie is topped with tender chicken, crisp vegetables, and a creamy coconut curry sauce, finished with a sprinkle of fresh cilantro. A bold, aromatic delight of a dish.
The kale-artichoke dip is fantastic too—creamy with just enough artichoke bite. Manager Cole and the friendly staff keep things running smoothly, whether you’re here for a date night or a casual meal with friends. With good food at reasonable prices (most pizzas around $18–$22) and a great draft and cocktail selection, it’s easy to see why this place is a top choice.
Jim’s Razorback Pizza
$ | (479) 527-6701 | WEBSITE
A family-owned pizza joint from the folks who’ve been serving Fayetteville for years, Jim’s Razorback Pizza is a beloved little takeaway spot. Just like its reputation suggests, Jim’s focuses on the simple things done well. Balls of handmade pizza dough line the kitchen, thick cuts of fresh vegetables and real cheese come out on pies, and the offer of extra sauce on pizzas is almost as tempting as those garlic cheese sticks on the side.
The menu doesn’t extend much beyond excellent pizzas and sandwiches, but everything is prepared and priced with care.
