In Forest Hills, where artisanal pizza shops multiply like mushrooms after rain, finding a truly great slice feels increasingly like a treasure hunt. Yet these seven pizza restaurants—each with its own crusty personality and loyal following—prove that exceptional pies still thrive in Queens. Grab a napkin and prepare for a deliciously unpretentious tour of the neighborhood’s best ovens.
Singas Famous Pizza
$ | (718) 459-3441 | WEBSITE
Singas Famous Pizza is tucked along a busy Forest Hills street, with meter parking out front and free spots down 63 Drive. There’s a simple counter, a few tables for watching the game, and the smell of crisp crust and melted cheese. But unlike most delivery joints, they serve consistently delicious pizza you can order without worrying about soggy disappointment.
Austin Street Pizza
$ | (347) 809-4195 | WEBSITE
Austin Street Pizza is a pizzeria on Austin Street in Forest Hills, NY. It’s a good spot to grab a slice during lunch or dinner and enjoy the atmosphere, along with a few pies. We usually eat here.
Dante’s Pizza
$ | (718) 544-0416 | WEBSITE
Nothing at this Forest Hills pizzeria appears to have been updated since the 1990s, and we mean that as the highest praise. The counter is worn smooth from decades of leaning elbows, and the vinyl booths cradle you comfortably so you can focus on the food. The cheese pie arrives with a crust that’s crisp yet gentle, topped with well-seasoned sauce and plenty of melted cheese—it satisfies every craving for a classic New York slice.
The garlic knots are some of the best around, served warm and garlicky. For entrees, the penne vodka and Eggplant Rolitini deliver hearty, flavorful comfort. The staff are professional and welcoming, interacting with customers respectfully while keeping service fast. With plenty of seating and affordable prices that undercut other spots in the area, Dante’s remains a neighborhood gem where the classics are done right.
Tuscan Hills
$$ | (718) 487-4500 | WEBSITE
You might do a double take when you spot the charming Tuscan Hills sign. But the Italian authenticity doesn’t stop at the entrance. Inside, it’s all warm wood, cozy lighting, and smiling servers. It’s a welcoming spot—unless you’re looking for modern sleekness. The place shows some charming wear. The bread with that salty dipping oil made with minced black olives and olive oil starts things right. Their pizzas are delicious, and the zucchini flowers are a must-try.
The tiramisu is creamy with perfect sweetness, even winning over skeptics. The service is outstanding, and the ambience feels truly Italian. It’s a genuine experience with tasty dishes and friendly faces, though the restrooms could use some attention. Overall, it’s a cozy, charming slice of Italy.
Radici
$$ | (718) 535-5663 | WEBSITE
This Italian spot in Forest Hills doesn’t look like much from the outside. But it has a cozy dining room, a small full bar, warm lighting, and they make everything from the fresh seafood pasta to the homemade cavatelli from scratch. The tagliatelle with Bolognese sauce is one of Forest Hills’ best.
D’Angelo’s Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant
$ | (718) 261-5900 | WEBSITE
This spot draws a curious mix of folks—families grabbing quick slices after school, construction workers in dusty boots, and your everyday locals seeking affordable pizza and pasta. But you’re here for their pepperoni pizza, a glorious behemoth that oozes greasy goodness with every bite.
Pizza & Pasta City
$ | (718) 896-6667 | WEBSITE
Forest Hills is the last place you’d expect to find a great slice, but Pizza & Pasta City provides a reliable option for anyone looking to grab a crispy pie while watching families enjoy late-night dinners. You can also get delivery, which will satisfy all your carb cravings.
