If Hagerstown were a pizza, its crust would be that sturdy foundation holding everything together. It’s full of family-owned joints, strip-mall surprises, and places where locals grab slices after Little League games – and there are plenty of pie options for everyone craving a taste. You’ll find everything from wood-fired Neapolitan spots for when you want to linger, to counter-service slices you can devour in your car while contemplating life’s cheesy mysteries.
Dolce – Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza
$ | (301) 745-6300 | WEBSITE
You can only order delivery from the same old pizza chain so many times before needing to head to Dolce and try their Eastern European specialties. Like a lot of other cozy neighborhood spots, there are a few different pasta dishes that come with your choice of sauce or preparation. But the pizzas here are better than what you’ll find at most casual dining places with their own online ordering systems.
They come with perfectly crisp crusts, rich tomato sauce, quality cheeses, and your choice of toppings (the four-cheese and the ricotta-topped options are both really good). While the restaurant itself is a tiny place, there’s a warm and welcoming atmosphere inside with wooden tables and soft lighting that make it perfect for lingering over a meal.
Café del Sol – Hagerstown East
$$ | (240) 707-6276 | WEBSITE
Café del Sol – Hagerstown East is another spot from the same local group. It’s just a short drive east, and it’s essentially the same concept, but with a slightly different menu focus (like those standout Bao Sliders and the Cuban Panini). It gets pretty crowded around the lunch rush, but if you’re after something tasty and reliable, it’s still one of your solid choices in the area.
There’s also a decent amount of seating in the clean, well-decorated space, but it tends to get taken fast, and if you want a quieter spot, your best move is the smaller tables near the back.
Café Roma Ristorante
$$ | (301) 739-8669 | WEBSITE
Café Roma Ristorante serves some of the best Italian food in Hagerstown, and the only reason it can be tough to recommend for dinner is that there’s almost always a long wait for a table (they only take reservations for events). But at lunch, not only is it less of a zoo, but they have reasonably priced luncheon specials that include a soup or salad.
They serve the same great dishes, with fantastic options like thin and delicious pizza, fried calamari, and ossobuco, which many customers have praised. The white pizza, short rib ravioli, and chicken cacciatore are particularly popular, and the simple decor with pieces by local artisans adds to the welcoming atmosphere filled with vintage Italian music.
The staff, especially Alex, goes above and beyond to ensure a smooth and memorable experience, making it highly recommended for anyone seeking authentic, fresh, and flavorful Italian cuisine.
Dino’s Pizza
$ | (301) 739-0788 | WEBSITE
On a typical evening with clear skies, it’s not unusual to spot 20+ cars parked around the building waiting for pizza from this spot, and with good cause. The pies are outstanding, and $12 will get you a cheese steak sub to brag about to your friends.
Rocky’s New York Pizza
$ | (301) 791-6810 | WEBSITE
Many people in Hagerstown have their favorite pizza joints, but the savvy ones head to Rocky’s New York Pizza. It’s probably best described as the upper end of the casual spots, which means it’s quality without breaking the bank for a quick lunch. Most of the lunch specials are around $7, but if you’re going to indulge, the big draw is the $12 cheesesteak sub with those crispy French fries.
The place has that nostalgic 1980s decor with vinyl booths and neon signs that make you feel like you’ve stepped back in time. The staff is always polite and friendly, which adds to that welcoming pizza parlor atmosphere everyone loves. Whether you’re grabbing that perfect New York slice with just the right cheese-to-sauce ratio or trying one of their delicious steak subs, Rocky’s delivers exactly what you want from a classic pizza spot.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (301) 766-9030 | WEBSITE
There are a few locations of Domino’s Pizza, and the one in Hagerstown is on a busy street corner. And despite the fact that it’s in a standard strip-mall storefront with fluorescent lighting, it still manages to feel like your neighborhood pizza spot. Stop by for a quick pick-up order, or just come by and grab a box of cheesy bread. The pizza here is great, and (possibly due to the fact that it’s so reliable) it doesn’t get the credit it should.
The staff, like Delaney and Rhett, are friendly and hardworking, delivering on time with a smile. Affordable prices and quick service make it a go-to choice for a satisfying meal.
Anthony’s Pizza
$ | (301) 665-1100 | WEBSITE
If the pizza you happen to crave is a little closer to classic than gourmet, then the Anthony’s Pizza near Aldi should be your Anthony’s. It’s nearly identical to other neighborhood spots, but with a little more cozy atmosphere.
Cafe Del Sol
$ | (301) 739-3072 | WEBSITE
It’s no secret, but this cozy pizza spot is really reliable. It’s pretty much a classic American diner with a twist, offering pizza and tacos alongside cheesesteak sandwiches – and you’ll be able to get a satisfying meal for around $12. The location gets pleasantly lively with 80’s and classic rock tunes during dinner hours, but the friendly staff always keeps things comfortable and attentive.
Pretzel and Pizza Creations
$ | (301) 733-7795 | WEBSITE
Pretzel and Pizza Creations is a pizza spot that’s cozy enough for a family dinner, and casual enough for a quick bite while exploring Hagerstown. Go with the $20 combo, which includes an appetizer and pizza, like the crab dip and Angry Bee pizza, as well as a dessert, like the milkshake that’s one of the best in town.
Kings New York Pizza
$ | (301) 745-6406 | WEBSITE
In an ideal world, you’d cook dinner every evening, and it would consist of things like steamed broccoli, grilled chicken, and other stuff that you assume is very good for you. In other words, you’d cook a dinner very similar to what you can get at Kings New York Pizza.
This pizza spot serves food like hot, cheesy pizzas, steak and cheese subs, mozzarella sticks, and baked ziti, and it’s perfect for when you need to feel like a happy human who eats things with melted cheese and perfectly browned crust.
Castello’s Pizzeria & Tex Mex
$ | (301) 791-9000 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a solid takeout option in Hagerstown, head to Castello’s Pizzeria & Tex Mex. Not only does this local spot serve some of the best pizza in the area, but it’s also located inside Kenley Village, in a clean, straightforward space that’s easy to access for pickup. The $18 large taco pizza includes that amazing sauce with a slight sweetness and a chewy crust that folds perfectly.
Everything on the menu is enjoyable, but the best part of the meal here is the friendly, prompt service that makes getting your food a breeze.
Paradise NY Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant
$ | (240) 382-1104 | WEBSITE
Paradise NY Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant is a local gem that’s especially good to know about if you want to work crispy, flavorful pizza into your dinner routine. It serves delicious and fresh-tasting dishes, and you can get a satisfying meal for around $15 – including the Birria pizza and a side of mozzarella sticks. The crust has a good color, and the staff are friendly and professional, making customers feel welcome and valued.
This family-owned business is a great alternative to chain pizza places, with its outstanding taste and excellent service.
The 301 Tacos & Pizza
$ | (240) 850-8537 | WEBSITE
Depending on where you live in Hagerstown, you’ll either find it a convenient gem or a surprising discovery that one of the best pizza spots in town is located at The 301 Tacos & Pizza. Under new management that’s clearly improved the place, it’s become a local favorite with a lively atmosphere. They serve the same delicious pepperoni pizza with perfect crust and tasty flavors as before, along with bacon cheese fries and boneless wings that keep guests coming back.
The staff is attentive and welcoming, making it work if you want to dine in and enjoy the friendly service.
American Pie Pizzeria
$ | (301) 582-6281 | WEBSITE
Run by a friendly owner who keeps the place spotless, American Pie Pizzeria specializes in thick-crust pizza. To get here, you walk into a space that’s clean and a little too straightforward, but we like the fact that you can specify how crispy you would like your pepperoni cups and that you can tell them how generous you would like your cheese, from loaded (lots of pull) to moderate (please hold). Choose wisely.
Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria
$ | (240) 420-6677 | WEBSITE
Ask anyone who lives in Hagerstown how often they hit Cafe Italia, and they might blush at their answer. This is a very reliable Italian spot in the area, and it’s the kind of place that can turn a rough day around. There’s a cozy dining room if you have time to sit, and a take-out counter that usually has a steady stream of regulars (and moves pretty efficiently).
The super Italian sub is the first thing you should try here, but they also have full plates like the cheese tortellini with meat sauce and the chicken cacciatore that come with their fresh-baked bread. Plus, you get a small scoop of that imported vanilla gelato with every meal.
Brothers Pizza Hagerstown
$ | (240) 625-9215 | WEBSITE
Brothers Pizza Hagerstown isn’t our top choice for pizza in Hagerstown, but it’s a reliable backup for when you can’t get into a more popular spot. The pizza here is consistently good and not overly pricey, and the atmosphere is straightforward and family-friendly, with a couple of convenient grab-and-go counters near the entrance. Plus, the service is efficient and friendly.
Little Alex’s Pizzeria
$ | (240) 850-2930 | WEBSITE
A serious pizza for serious cravings, Little Alex’s Pizzeria is a very authentic local spot, where it seems like genuine care went into each and every bite of cheese curds, Cuban panini, or warm homemade crust. You’re going to want an appetite and plenty of time to savor it.
