We’ve never tossed dough in Naples or tended a wood-fired oven in Brooklyn, though serious props to those who do. Instead, we like ours stretched, topped, baked to bubbly perfection, and served with a cold beer and good company. If you, too, are craving a proper slice right now, start with these top pizza spots in Plymouth.
Zesto’s Deli & Pizzeria
$ | (508) 747-4400 | WEBSITE
Plymouth has plenty of pizza spots, but Zesto’s Deli & Pizzeria is our top pick in town. The unassuming, family-run deli serves hearty, satisfying sandwiches and pizzas that you can grab to go. There’s a cozy dining area with checkered tablecloths and local photos, plus a few outdoor tables out front.
The menu is perfect for groups with different tastes—and you’ll notice many regulars here—since everything is uncomplicated, like the Cuban sandwich piled high with roast pork and ham, or the Chicken Salad Sub made with tender chopped chicken and just enough mayo. We especially love the generous portions served at wallet-friendly prices (seriously, you’ll leave full and happy).
Rose & Vicki’s in Cedarville
$ | (508) 888-2822 | WEBSITE
This is our go-to casual spot for reliably delicious chicken parm subs and generously topped pizzas shared with a group of friends (these dishes aren’t meant to be eaten alone, after all). And while the subs are the real stars of the menu, Rose & Vicki’s also does some delicious larger plates like perfectly cooked pizzas with generous toppings and baskets of fries.
A meal here is meant to be enjoyed with convenient parking and access to nearby amenities, as Rose & Vicki’s prides itself on its fabulous location. The best time to come is during regular hours, which draws a loyal crowd thanks to $12 subs, $18 pizzas, and “it’s-a-safe-bet” vibes.
Cappy’s Pizza
$ | (508) 224-6868 | WEBSITE
If you’re after the best pizza in Plymouth, make your way to Cappy’s. The laid-back spot is filled with locals in sneakers thinking about Naples or Sicily while the aroma of fresh dough in the air reminds them they’re just a few miles from home. You’ll notice plenty of subs and rice bowls being served around the dining room, but don’t let that sidetrack you. You need the perfectly crisp chicken piccata with homemade pasta and the golden onion rings that taste just as good as they look.
Stop by for a relaxed meal with family or friends.
Monte Christos Restaurant
$ | (508) 224-7000 | WEBSITE
This cozy pizza joint in Plymouth trades fancy toppings and artisanal crusts for thick-cut onion rings and homemade Greek dressing. The restaurant feels like a time capsule—simple booths and tables arranged in a familiar, welcoming layout. The warm walls are dotted with family photos and local memorabilia, and the whole space has that comforting vibe of a neighborhood spot, which feels just right as you bite into a crunchy onion ring.
Come here for an easy lunch with kids or just to enjoy a flavorful pastrami sub and tender grilled chicken salad with friends on a weekend afternoon.
The Edge – Thick Square Pizza – Plymouth
$ | (508) 233-8605 | WEBSITE
You might think there are a lot of good pizza options in Plymouth, but gone are the days of thin-crust joints and generic chains. And while none of the pizza here can touch what was happening in the olden days, we’ll swing by The Edge for a relatively affordable, grab-and-go square of thick-crust pizza. It’s a great place to wrangle hungry kids who are fed up with taking family pictures in front of the water.
Grab a seat at one of the wooden tables or take your cardboard boxes of Buffalo bacon ranch pizza to the casual dining area right inside.
Mamma Mia’s Restaurants
$$ | (508) 747-4670 | WEBSITE
While you can order classic pizza and pasta at this Water Street spot, their waterfront views and rooftop terrace are why you come here. Enjoy your meal indoors or on the wrap-around deck with umbrella tables, or head upstairs to the roof terrace, where you can pair it with sunshine, beautiful weather, and delicious food.
Gillis Family Tavern
$$ | (508) 746-0056 | WEBSITE
Don’t overlook this Plymouth gem when you’re craving pizza in Massachusetts. This charming tavern serves delicious—and reasonably priced—pies that you can enjoy in a cozy, rustic setting. We love the perfectly fried fish sandwich with the restaurant’s own batter that’s just a little crispy.
Family Pizza Plymouth
$ | (508) 747-7474 | WEBSITE
In Plymouth there’s pizza, and then there’s Family Pizza pizza. And while a meal here won’t break the bank, the food is good enough to make you forget about counting calories (at least until the last slice is gone). Family Pizza has the hallmarks of what a local favorite is known for—it’s reliable, super quick, and filled with regulars, but what sets it apart is the consistently tasty dishes coming out of the kitchen.
Focused on classic comfort food, the menu revolves around hearty Italian-American staples. We love the Hawaiian pizza with generous pineapple to start, as well as the chicken parm and lasagna, both of which can satisfy at least two hungry people. Some dishes, like the chicken finger and curly fries plate, are served as complete meals, so you’ll want to save room for the sides—and you can’t go wrong with the non-greasy onion rings and the calzones.
Plymouth House Pizzeria & Pub
$ | (508) 746-0444 | WEBSITE
In a town where the main attractions are often crowded with tourists and their families, Plymouth House Pizzeria & Pub offers a genuine retreat. Unlike many spots in Plymouth, the atmosphere here is less about souvenir shopping and more about savoring perfectly crispy pizza crusts. It seems like everyone has come with the simple goal of indulging in chicken parm and enjoying a cold beer in the shaded outdoor seating.
The menu lets you choose your favorite—options include standout pizzas, fresh salads, and hearty subs—paired with classics like shrimp marsala with linguine and garlic bread. It’s hard to go wrong with their service, but we love how accommodating waitress Rochelle is, making sure every custom order arrives just right.
Sal’s Pizza | Plymouth, MA
$ | (978) 650-2371 | WEBSITE
One of the most unexpected gems in Plymouth, Sal’s Pizza is what the town needed—a spot casual enough to grab a quick slice without any fuss, but also tasty and satisfying enough to make it a regular stop. The pizza joint, tucked inside a gas station, excels in the value experience with generously-proportioned quarter slices priced between $5 and $7, each large enough to be cut in half. Not in the mood for a classic slice?
Their meat lovers pizza, which tastes just like a north end pizza, and the specialty chicken bacon ranch with its tasty ranch drizzle are more distinctive—but still outstanding—choices.
