When Prescott Valley’s pizza ovens fire up, our appetites perk up like a certain mustachioed plumber spotting a power-up. It gives us an excuse to dust off our stretchy pants, order extra garlic knots, and debate crust styles without shame. The town boasts its share of pie-slinging spots that go all out for the slice if you need to be immersed in bubbling, golden cheese or complete your topping bucket list.
Rosa’s Pizzeria (Prescott Valley)
$ | (928) 277-0633 | WEBSITE
Rosa’s Pizzeria is making its mark as one of Prescott Valley’s top pizza destinations. Prepare to enjoy as many garlic knots, fried artichoke hearts, and perfectly topped slices as the welcoming dining room and wonderful patio can handle. Plus, there’s space to relax to some great background music. Pizzas start at around $18, and the atmosphere is family-friendly throughout the evening.
Ciao Bella Italian Restaurant
$$ | (928) 756-2783 | WEBSITE
Ciao Bella has a standout pizza menu that’s been updated for 2026. You can swing by this Prescott Valley spot for their tender chicken piccata, shrimp Portofino, or a generous slice of their delicious pizza. If you’re in the mood for something rich, try the incredible mac-n-cheese or the great Bolognese, and you’ll receive a complimentary glass of Lambrusco. The house garlic knots are extremely soft and fresh on the weekends, so bring your appetite for their signature tiramisu.
Guido’s Pizza
$ | (928) 632-5950 | WEBSITE
Guido’s Pizza is partnering with its regulars for its Friday night date night tradition. The family-friendly spot has a more welcoming take on its neighborhood vibe, which includes specialty pizzas featuring sauce with a slightly sweet flavor. The assortment of meats and Italian goods is available for purchase, which means the wings and ice cream can find their new home in your takeout order.
Tailgaters & IL Primo Prescott Valley
$ | (928) 775-0000 | WEBSITE
ThisPrescottValleysportsbarandpizzaspot rolls out the game-day spirit best—with brews. In addition to a few sports TVs decorating their space, you can expect a beer list curated for the lively crowd. Like the local IPA, which features hoppy notes and a crisp finish. To keep things as sports-bar-y as possible, Tailgaters & IL Primo only serves some of these pours if it’s truly game-time (during happy hour) inside.
Pizza Hut
$ | (928) 775-0906 | WEBSITE
If you’re craving a reliable pizza fix, head to Pizza Hut this January. Expect to find a warm, welcoming, and clean environment with shiny floors and clean tables. The buffet offers tasty options like the new hot honey pizza and wings. If you like a little sweetness, the pineapple pizza features a buttery crust. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing quick and efficient service. The management stands out and the whole team works together. It’s a place worth revisiting for a casual meal.
Pizza Place
$ | (928) 772-8234 | WEBSITE
Pizza Place welcomes families with a kid-friendly environment and a menu that offers slices for little ones. There are some classic options, like the generously cheesy pies that make it a standout. But you can also look forward to lighter choices for lactose intolerant guests, with staff happy to hold back the cheese. You can grab a table or find ample parking if you’d rather drive in.
Rusty’s Subs, Pizza & Wings
$ | (928) 775-2632 | WEBSITE
For the sixth year in a row, Rusty’s Subs, Pizza & Wings in Prescott Valley is serving their classic menu. This spot is decked out in simple, clean decor and features a straightforward selection of favorites, including the meatball sub, where tender meatballs, marinara, and melted cheese all find themselves on the same roll. Grab a seat and order a side of their famous French fries as a treat.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (928) 775-8787 | WEBSITE
If you find yourself in Prescott Valley, Papa Johns Pizza will also deliver right to your door for any occasion. The pizza chain will also serve their classic menu, which includes fresh options like pepperoni pizza made with quality ingredients, cheesy breadsticks, and garlic dipping sauce. Order ahead of time for dinner, but you’ll have to try your luck during peak hours when wait times might stretch a bit longer.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (928) 775-7171 | WEBSITE
Papa Murphy’s, a reliable take-and-bake spot in Prescott Valley, is thriving with its welcoming atmosphere and great pizza selection. Walk into the clean, bright space and chat with the friendly, efficient staff who prepare your order in minutes. Grab your fresh, customizable pie with clear baking instructions for a hot meal at home. They even offer veteran discounts and good specials for an easy, tasty experience.
Encanto Italian Grill
$ | (928) 775-5500 | WEBSITE
It’s practically always a cozy neighborhood gathering at Encanto Italian Grill with their consistently warm, inviting atmosphere, and when the dinner rush hits, the Prescott Valley spot really comes alive. No regular is overlooked here, so stop by when you want to enjoy a slice of thin crust pizza while feeling like you’re part of the family.
