Whether you’re planning a casual Friday night with friends or seeking that perfect slice to impress a first date, pizza night should always feel special. From classic Neapolitan pies that transport you to Italy to innovative toppings that spark conversation, Ridgewood’s pizza scene offers something for every craving and occasion. Let these 15 standout spots guide your next delicious adventure.
S.Egidio Pizze Salumi Espresso
$$ | (201) 389-3525 | WEBSITE
S.Egidio Pizze Salumi Espresso’s refined yet welcoming ambiance is perfect when your usual pizza joint’s fluorescent lights and greasy countertops don’t exactly scream family dinner. All of the pizzas from their great coal oven are well-crafted and part of a focused menu (standouts include the mind-blowing Nutella calzone and pizzas with great cheese). Plus, they also have a thoughtful selection of drinks like the Basil white sangria that complement the food.
And it’s no surprise that the service is exceptional since S.Egidio Pizze Salumi Espresso is known for its quick, professional table turnaround and attentive, knowledgeable staff.
Mangiamo Pizza Restaurant & Catering
$ | (201) 225-0555 | WEBSITE
Expand your pizza night into a full Italian feast by introducing Mangiamo into the mix. This pizza restaurant-catering hybrid from the Mangiamo team is the perfect place for a family dinner with everyone. The staff serves pizza with outstanding crust and fresh, generous toppings to cheesy perfection from the oven, and you can get saucy by dipping the crust into garlic oil or marinara before eating it as is or making a little salad wrap.
Classics on the menu are also excellent, like pasta cooked to perfection or vibrant salads. And though Mangiamo’s location in Ridgewood guarantees many locals inside the homey yet charming space, one bite of that bursting-with-flavor pizza will charm even the most takeout-allergic diners into having a satisfying meal.
Biby’s Empanadas & Pizza
$ | (201) 773-0144 | WEBSITE
Biby’s Empanadas & Pizza is a charming neighborhood spot for excellent Argentine-style pizza, empanadas, and a little Ridgewood comfort. It feels like a family home that’s been transformed into a warm restaurant that’s perfect for a casual meal with someone you actually enjoy spending time with. The energy pairs homey-casual with authentic warmth-by-wooden-tables, and the food and service only add to its inviting charm.
Get the Argentine Pizza Deluxe with its perfect crunch and delicious taste, or empanadas that come with a side of incredible Chimichurri sauce. Thankfully, those incredible empanadas come in a variety of options—beef, chicken, spinach—so there’s no worry about monotony ruining a great meal.
Mario’s pizza & Pasta
$ | (201) 845-6556 | WEBSITE
What do you want out of a neighborhood pizzeria? Tradition? Comfort? Delicious New York-style pies in a classic BYOB space that manages to be both bustling and welcoming? Well, Mario’s Pizza & Pasta in Ridgewood can at least help with the last bit. You can join the other families and regulars digging into fugazzeta with sautéed onions and oregano or Argentina-style steak sandwiches—all of which are recipes inspired by the owners’ heritage.
Who knows, a slice of bubbling, cheese-laden pizza might just successfully remind you of why this place has been a community favorite for years.
Pizza Town USA
$ | (201) 797-6172 | WEBSITE
Pizza Town USA is nestled in a bustling part of Ridgewood where you can grab a classic pizza meal in nostalgic comfort. It’s a Brooklyn-style spot that’s been serving the same beloved pies for over 60 years, and they have a straightforward menu with excellent, time-tested items like the thin-crust pizza with San Marzano sauce and a remarkably good chicken cutlet sandwich.
And while the dining area is filled with checkered tablecloths and looks like a vintage pizzeria, it’s not dated—the space is lively and welcoming thanks to friendly staff and late-night hours that keep the energy up.
Wahizza Ridgefield Park
$ | (201) 870-6059 | WEBSITE
If your craving is for phenomenal crust and you have ‘pizza purist’ in your Instagram bio, this Ridgewood spot with a cozy dining room has you covered. Their menu features a delicious range of flavorful pizzas—classics, fusion creations, and a few that have become local legends. Wahizza also serves up amazing dishes like the fried calamari and chicken parm pizza, with gluten-free options available upon request.
The warm space decked out in simple decor has plenty of tables and a clean, welcoming atmosphere, but their friendly, attentive service guarantees that you can enjoy the meal wherever. The owners make it feel like a meal at home, and the impeccable bathroom shows they care about the details. With fresh food that’s a work of art and fast service that makes diners feel welcomed, this is a favorite spot for regulars and newcomers alike.
Anthony Franco’s Pizza – Wayne
$ | (973) 633-8800 | WEBSITE
If you’ve ever wanted to have a party in the heart of a supportive community, head to Anthony Franco’s Pizza in Wayne. It’s a generous local business, and has a welcoming party room filled with friendly staff, great service, and fantastic food. The menu has dishes like amazing pizza pies, vodka fries, plus a selection of incredible wings (like boneless garlic parm).
Between the inviting atmosphere and convenient parking, Anthony Franco’s Pizza has the ability to make you feel special and magically make you forget that you’re just grabbing a meal.
Valentino’s Pizza & Pasta
$ | (201) 773-8293 | WEBSITE
This Ridgewood pizza joint had us wondering ‘Is this our new go-to spot?’ after the large pepperoni pie made us sigh with crispy-crust contentment. And by sharing that cheese pizza with a friend, maybe they’ll think ‘Is this my new favorite comfort food?’ But honestly, any menu item might spark that feeling—whether you order the well-prepared chicken cutlet, the fresh salad, or those recommended mozzarella sticks.
The clean, welcoming space always has a relaxed vibe and is ideal for a casual meal, especially if you’re catching up with neighbors nearby.
Dominick’s Pizza
$ | (973) 942-4141 | WEBSITE
Between its lively Friday night buzz, delicious pizza, and warm community vibe, Dominick’s Pizza is an ideal family dinner spot. This local pizzeria also has a cozy, inviting atmosphere, and we can’t think of a better way to spend an evening than sharing a fresh tomato garlic pie with some meatball parmigiana sandwiches while the accommodating staff makes everyone feel right at home.
Corleone’s Pizzeria
$ | (201) 426-5656 | WEBSITE
Corleone’s Pizzeria is a guaranteed great time regardless of why you’re here, a casual dinner with friends is no different. Their classic Italian-American pizzas—vodka pizza with its creamy sauce, combo pizza with sweet pineapple, and white pizza with garlic and ricotta—are so satisfying and comforting you’d probably still leave in a good mood even if the conversation ends up being a bust.
The appetizers are also delicious, like the crispy eggplant rollatini with marinara and garlic knots with herbed butter. And since there’s always a warm, neighborhood atmosphere with friendly staff who treat you like family, instead of worrying about parking or service, you can just relax and feel like part of the community.
Fast Pizza & Salad Bar
$ | (973) 925-7220 | WEBSITE
Not every family meal needs to be a ‘big production’—but when you are looking for a reliable ‘big production,’ check out Fast Pizza & Salad Bar in Ridgewood. First off, this pizza spot with its praised staff like Des, who handles phone orders with bubbly intelligence, operates in a welcoming, kid-friendly space, so dining in a place where the atmosphere feels like home already makes a statement.
But even if you don’t plan on a lengthy stay, eating incredible baked ziti pizza or favorites like BBQ chicken and fried raviolis with vodka sauce, all at reasonable prices, feels nothing short of satisfying.
Wayne Ale House & Pizza
$$ | (973) 706-5505 | WEBSITE
We’ll be honest, this Ridgewood pizza joint tucked away in a chill neighborhood spot is already packed most weekends. But if you swing by on a weeknight, they might have a table open—usually around 7pm and for a solid couple of hours. So while it’s not ideal for late-night lounging or those who hate a friendly crowd, there are definite perks.
Wayne Ale House’s relaxed space works perfectly for something casual without being too divey, largely helped by a soundtrack that doesn’t scream “date night.” And the pizzas like the Portnoy with its thin crispy crust, perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio, or the massive 2-foot diameter pie are all outstanding. The welcoming vibe is also great if you’re meeting friends before a game or need to wrap things up when the person you’re with ends up having less personality than the bartenders.
GRUMPY’S PIZZA CO. -SOURDOUGH PIZZA-
$ | (201) 880-0555 | WEBSITE
We’d happily show up to Grumpy’s for alone time with some excellent plain cheese slices, but it works equally well for a family night with the kids. Located in Ridgewood’s cozy neighborhood spot, it’s already a comforting experience just walking in.
And with its simple design and warm lighting, it’s perfect for family dinner when you’re ready to step up from “fast food casual.” Their sourdough pizzas are all great, like that crispy crust, the flavorful hot honey heaven, and a take on triple threat with red sauce, vodka sauce, and pesto. And if you get distracted during conversation after taking a bite of their delicious fried Oreos full of chocolatey goodness, don’t feel bad—chances are that will happen to your kids, too.
Puzo’s Family Restaurant
$ | (201) 445-3332 | WEBSITE
Puzo’s cozy space with its warm kitchen aromas and checkered tablecloths is perfect for a comforting family meal, whether it’s a casual weeknight dinner or you’re celebrating a special occasion. And the food at this intimate Ridgewood spot is just as heartwarming. Don’t be surprised if, mid-bite, you start reflecting on how the incredible penne vodka captures the essence of a grandmother’s Sunday sauce in a single bowl.
Throw in some slices of their personal pepperoni pizza, plus a very nostalgic Italian-American soundtrack, and you’ve got everything you need for a satisfying meal.
Bella Pizza Hasbrouck Heights
$ | (201) 426-0998 | WEBSITE
If you want some great pizza from a local favorite, head to this Ridgewood spot from the Bella Pizza team. The casual space is filled with regulars who have the same idea as you, but the service is very attentive, and it’s not too loud to relax. Inevitable conversation topics: the namesake pizza with its unique crispy yet chewy dough and the must-order mozzarella sticks. But if you briefly stop chatting to zone out into your well-made calzone, that’s perfectly normal.
