In the beforetimes, when pizza was just a Friday night staple, we launched a quest for the very best slices in Saint John – from wood-fired Neapolitans to loaded deep-dish pies, and everything in between.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (506) 693-5050 | WEBSITE
Why the hell are there such a limited number of deals available? Can’t they just… Anyway, if it’s consistently good pizza you’re after, I can’t recommend this reliable spot in the strip mall enough, specifically their pepperoni pizza, which comes with a generous amount of perfectly melted cheese and crispy pepperoni slices.
East Side Mario’s
$$ | (506) 799-5043 | WEBSITE
East Side Mario’s in Saint John serves my favorite pasta in the city. It’s the Linguine Chicken Tetrazzini with tender chicken and rich mushroom sauce, it costs about $18, and it’s perfect. But they’ve also got the area’s best Italian comfort food, from fresh garlic buns and creamy sauces to perfectly cooked pasta and flavorful trios. I always order the trio and some garlic bread, too, to make an extremely satisfying (and cozy) family meal.
Pizza Salvatoré
$ | (506) 652-5555 | WEBSITE
Yeah, it made our 12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Saint John list this year, but IMHO, there may not be a more underappreciated pizza in town than the Mediterranean pizza at Pizza Salvatoré. Loaded with toppings and stuffed with cheese in the crust, it’s simple, savory, satisfying, and certainly not the kind of thing you’d see on your Instagram feed – but what good pizza is?
Pizza Delight
$ | (506) 634-6814 | WEBSITE
Sometimes the highest form of self care is to just say f*ck it and order the Super Donair on pizza crust. Pizza Delight gets it. Pizza Delight always gets it.
Boston Pizza
$$ | (506) 657-7778 | WEBSITE
Boston Pizza makes all their pasta in-house, resulting in some excellent (and occasionally surprising) dishes, like the mountain smoky spaghetti, spinach artichoke dip, and incredible wings with fries.
Pizzano’s Pizza & Donairs
$ | (506) 672-1919 | WEBSITE
I’m working just down the street from Pizzano’s, so it’s become a weekly lunch spot for me. There are several different pizza options on the menu, ranging from $12-25, so whatever you (and your appetite) are in the mood for today, they’ll have you covered.
Romano’s
$ | (506) 672-5000 | WEBSITE
On Friday night, I grabbed Romano’s classic pepperoni pizza – arguably the best pie in Saint John – and it was nearly as satisfying as dining in. A generous twelve-inch pie with their signature sauce, fresh toppings, and that perfect crust for just $22. I’ll be ordering again next week.
Big Daddy’s
$ | (506) 652-4422 | WEBSITE
A regular at the Lansdowne Plaza (Thanks, Sarah!) tipped me off that this family-friendly spot has been perfecting their donair sub, and I’m thrilled she did – their version (sweet, garlicky, and slathered in butter) is outstanding. Rest assured, you can still enjoy their signature square pizzas with that light, crunchy crust, too.
Greco Pizza
$$ | (506) 634-0033 | WEBSITE
The fact that Greco Pizza is doing takeout at all is impressive. The fact they’re doing a party pizza and calzone meal deal for only $22 is borderline incredible. I was worried it might not be that much food, but I was quickly proven wrong. The pizza is huge, the toppings are generous, and I was extremely satisfied when it was over.
Papa John’s Pizza
$ | (506) 657-7272 | WEBSITE
If you’re craving a pizza night that won’t disappoint, then it’s time to treat yourself to some of the best delivery pizza in Saint John. Papa John’s consistently delivers a pizza experience that exceeds expectations with their commitment to quality ingredients. Their menu caters to different tastes, from classic pepperoni to specialty pizzas with fresh toppings and generously layered cheese.
The crust offers that perfect balance of chewy and crispy, and the sauce strikes just the right tangy-savory balance. Sure it’s “just pizza,” but just like their friendly staff who help customize orders exactly how you want them, that really means everything.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (506) 649-2002 | WEBSITE
This Little Caesars Pizza in Saint John is my go-to when I’m feeding the family on a budget. Their stuffed crust pizza – especially with extra sauce – is so satisfying it literally hits the spot, and goes great with a simple meal when you’re not planning anything fancy later. Just be prepared for some sarcastic attitude from the staff, and maybe skip it if you have sensitive digestion.
TOPS Eatery
$ | (506) 634-0505 | WEBSITE
Quite possibly my favorite pizza spot in all of Saint John, this comfortable eatery is known for their classic pies (for good reason), but my favorite things here are the authentic Indian street food additions, like the delightful pani puri and chole bhature. Though, to be honest, their consistently good, simple dishes at reasonable prices are the perfect choice for just about any occasion.
