Pizza – the quintessential American food we crave at lunch, dinner, and those late-night moments. But what about when the craving hits at that awkward afternoon hour, when nothing else will satisfy? In Stratford, CT, these ten pizzerias deliver perfection no matter the time on the clock.
La Fortuna Bar & Restaurant
$$ | (203) 923-2300 | WEBSITE
Your old college roommate is visiting, and you’re showing them around Stratford. But you just spent an hour debating whether to get pizza or pasta, and now you’re absolutely famished. There’s nothing that hits the spot on Main Street, so make the quick drive over to La Fortuna Bar & Restaurant. The cozy, welcoming spot has delicious food, generous portions, and a specific “home-cooked Italian” vibe that’s perfect for both lunch and dinner.
The friendly and attentive staff make you feel right at home, and the wild mushrooms with scallops and risotto or the classic chicken parmesan are exactly what you need. It’s all about great value here—you’ll leave full and happy without breaking the bank.
Paradise Pizza Restaurant
$ | (203) 377-0476 | WEBSITE
You felt the craving building all week and it’s finally here. Friday night, empty fridge, family gathering – time for pizza. But after one delivery app turned into five, you’re suddenly overwhelmed and nothing sounds right. Except Paradise Pizza. The friendly Stratford spot is open for large orders and cooking up some of the better bar pizza in Connecticut. Think Greek style pizza, cheeseburger pizza, and plenty of crispy wings. Time to satisfy the soul.
The Parlor
$$ | (203) 522-5055 | WEBSITE
You just wrapped up a Saturday morning soccer game at Short Beach Park, and your kid scored the winning goal. Time to celebrate. The Parlor might just have the best individual-sized pizzas in Stratford, with that unique crust offering just the right chew. The Caesar salad comes with white balsamic dressing that’s dangerously addictive (probably the perfect balance of tang and sweetness).
The kid-friendly space is fun but relaxed, and though it can get pretty crowded during dinner rushes, 11:30am on a weekend will be clear sailing. At around $15-20 per pizza, it’s a solid value for the generous portions, and the hand-cut fries could easily feed two. The exposed brick walls and warm lighting make it feel cozy without trying too hard—exactly the kind of spot where you can unwind after a morning win. Don’t skip the spicy BBQ vegan option, even if you’re not vegan; it’s that good.
Service is quick and friendly, and they handle events like graduation parties seamlessly. Sure, some pizza purists might argue there are more traditional spots nearby, but for creative pies that actually satisfy a crowd, The Parlor nails it every time.
Dal Mare Pizzeria
$ | (203) 870-8877 | WEBSITE
There are just those days when cooking feels impossible and you’re stuck working late in your cozy Stratford home office – we understand. But you need to eat eventually, and your best bet is Dal Mare Pizzeria. Open for both lunch and dinner, this friendly Italian spot is definitely a neighborhood favorite, but the food is always delicious.
You can’t go wrong with any of their pizzas, but if you’re craving something heartier (who isn’t?), their eggplant parmesan and meatballs are homemade classics.
Gregory’s Pizza
$ | (203) 377-4683 | WEBSITE
You just finished a grueling workweek and need some serious comfort food. Thankfully, one of the most reliable pizza joints in Stratford is ready to deliver exactly that. Gregory’s Pizza is technically a neighborhood pizza place, but their kitchen turns out some truly satisfying classics. It’s straightforward, with familiar options on the menu, but each one delivers the kind of quality that makes a tough day feel better.
Order ahead for pickup to skip the wait, and settle in at home with your feast.
Delizioso Brick Oven Pizza
$ | (203) 908-4444 | WEBSITE
Stratford’s best pizza spot you’ve never heard of? That would be Delizioso. Over the past few years, it’s built a quiet cult following for its tremendous brick oven pizza – and not just by Stratford’s standards either. Its location isn’t exactly what you’d consider in the middle of things – but if it’s 7pm and you’re roaming the Stratford streets looking for pizza, Delizioso’s huge, casual space with that New Haven-style vibe is exactly what the doctor ordered.
Fairfield Pizza
$ | (203) 378-5552 | WEBSITE
One of our favorite pizza joints in the Stratford area, Fairfield Pizza is open every day from 11am – 10pm. These aren’t the most gourmet pies in town, but we don’t care. They’re still delicious, and the laid-back new atmosphere with its bar is ideal for a quick 5pm drop-in. We love a good hole-in-the-wall spot as much as the next person, but sometimes it’s nice to step into some great new ambiance, grab a huge slice, and watch the friendly, efficient crew make people laugh while they work.
Big Jim’s Galley
$$ | (203) 549-9842 | WEBSITE
Nobody ever really wants to polish off an entire pizza in front of a stranger, but that meeting keeps getting pushed back and now it’s 4pm and you’re starving. Head to Big Jim’s Galley. The popular spot in Stratford is what seafood and pizza dreams are made of, and though they close at 6pm, they go strong until the finish line. So order that clam scampi pizza or lobster mac and cheese or whatever else looks good (aka everything), and don’t apologize for a thing.
Honeyspot Pizza
$ | (203) 380-0707 | WEBSITE
You’ve been running errands all afternoon, you just spent an hour at the DMV, and you might lose your mind if you have to wait another minute for dinner. Breathe easy and head to Honeyspot Pizza. The fact that this place gets orders ready within half an hour is not just a relief for your immediate hunger, but for the neighborhood overall.
This straightforward, reliable pizza spot in Stratford is one of the best around, and with pick-up, you get to skip any potential wait and enjoy terrific food at home.
Di Roma’s Pizzeria of Stratford,Connecticut
$ | (203) 612-7797 | WEBSITE
Admittedly, almost every pizza joint in Stratford stays open late, but we had to pick one, and it’s Di Roma’s Pizzeria. Not only is the food consistently good here, the atmosphere and feel is as close to a classic neighborhood Italian spot that we have in this town. You’ll grab a quick slice, the margarita pizza, and relax comfortably in whatever worn-in booth is available near the counter.
