Is your ideal slice a classic Neapolitan, or do you crave a Detroit-style square? Whether your speed is a no-frills corner joint or a wood-fired temple to fermentation, Westminster’s pizza scene delivers. From crisp-crusted pies to pillowy focaccia-style slabs, these eight spots—serving everything from Calabrian chili-topped rounds to Vietnamese-inspired creations—are where you’ll find the city’s most compelling slices.
Big Rob’s Pizzeria
$ | (714) 891-1148 | WEBSITE
At this pizza spot in Westminster, pizza-making is a genuine craft. You’ll find things like the Meat Lovers pizza that’s loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, or their signature crispy crust that’s perfectly balanced with cheese and sauce. You might have to navigate the small space, but treat this place like a real dining destination and it’ll be worth it. Get your food to stay, and enjoy the clean, quiet atmosphere.
They sometimes even have some tasty wings, cooked to perfection and served hot.
Calixtos pizza
$ | (714) 842-4999 | WEBSITE
For a slightly sweet, ultra-spicy treat in Huntington, head to Calixtos Pizza, a family-run, pizza-making spot that consistently delivers the best slices in town. Order the secret menu Mango Habanero Pizza, loaded with sweet mango and fiery habanero, then marvel at how they manage to balance those bold flavors all on one crispy crust. Calixtos also makes a solid medium cheese pizza—perfectly crisp and cheesy—in case you need lunch and dinner. (That is what you need.)
Magic Mike’s Pizza
$ | (714) 898-0211 | WEBSITE
Do you remember that scene in a classic pizza movie where someone takes their first bite of a perfect slice and the world just stops? Here’s our pitch for the next great pizza moment: Same exact feeling, but swap in some equally crispy—and significantly more flavorful—lemon pepper wings. We nominate Magic Mike’s Pizza, a family-run spot in Westminster, as the go-to destination. Their wings are more or less what we imagine biting into pure crunch would taste like.
The outdoor seating with personal heat lamps creates a cozy vibe perfect for enjoying a beer, while the friendly staff makes you feel right at home. The gluten-free thick-crust pizza is a game-changer, and the cheesy garlic bread hits all the right notes. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a pesto pizza, appreciate the crispy thin crust, and leave feeling completely satisfied.
Renato’s Restaurant and Catering
$ | (714) 839-5755 | WEBSITE
When we stepped into this cozy Westminster restaurant and smelled fresh-baked dough, we immediately knew we were in for a good time. For fellow enthusiasts of classic Italian fare, we recommend the perfectly charred Margherita pizza, a pie loaded with fresh mozzarella and basil.
The pasta dishes are housemade, and Renato’s comforting lasagna is their bestseller for family gatherings, but our favorite menu item here might be the garlic knots—a lightly buttery, herb-speckled bread—served warm with marinara sauce for dipping.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (714) 897-2280 | WEBSITE
We never leave Domino’s Pizza in Westminster without ordering a large pepperoni pizza, a crispy, cheesy pie that’ll leave your fingers slightly greasy with savory flavor. And that’s just the meal we devour in three slices inside the car. The reliable chain also has some classic options like cheese pizzas, sandwiches, and breadsticks. It’s a straightforward space with just a few tables, so plan on taking your order to go. They also have an accurate pizza tracker online.
Michael’s Sports Pub & Grill
$ | (714) 373-5665 | WEBSITE
Michael’s Sports Pub & Grill in Westminster is a perfect spot to watch the game on a lively Friday night. In the spacious, well-lit space, choose from around 10 entertainment options by grabbing cues and pucks while classic rock plays over the sound of families celebrating. The daily specials menu consists mainly of Tequila chicken and affordable, late-night $11 pizzas after 9pm.
Make the perfect pairing: like a cold beer with a round of pool, or a friendly game of shuffleboard with a lesson from owner Michael himself.
Dino’s Italian Restaurant
$ | (714) 897-1552 | WEBSITE
Here it is, The Infatuation’s foolproof, three-step guide to becoming the most popular person in your family. Step 1: Drive over to Westminster and pull into Dino’s Italian Restaurant. Step 2: Order the Family Meal for a shockingly reasonable price (around $46), which comes with a large pizza, a mountain of those crispy chicken wings, and a side of that cheesy garlic bread, all packed up in sturdy, no-fuss containers.
Step 3: Bask in the adoration of your hungry crew, and enjoy the hot, satisfyingly cheesy feast with a cold drink.
Valuetina’s Pizza
$ | (714) 379-2500 | WEBSITE
This family-owned pizza joint with its spotless, welcoming atmosphere stays open late on weekends, making it the perfect post-movie or post-game stop in Westminster. Don’t skip the classic cheese pizza, a local favorite that hits that sweet spot between crispy and chewy. The perfect dough, fresh mozzarella, and that signature marinara sauce—a perfect blend of spices with just a hint of sweetness—come together in every satisfying bite.
The pepperoni pizza is a flavor powerhouse, loaded with generous toppings and high-quality ingredients that put chain restaurants to shame. You’ll be pretty full after a whole pie, but why not grab a custom half-and-half pizza to go for later?
