The ovens are roaring, the mozzarella is stretching, and Yonkers locals are planning their next ‘research trip’ to Arthur Avenue’s outskirts. It’s pizza season, always. If you’re one of the hungry masses ready to dive into a perfect slice—welcome. Second, let’s settle where to go first.
Dom & Vinnies Restaurant
$ | (914) 476-6666 | WEBSITE
The Sicilian pizzas from Dom & Vinnies in Yonkers are the size of a baking sheet. The classic version is topped with their signature grape-flavored crust and cheese, plus generous garlic that warrants keeping a breath mint in your pocket. The family-style option is their homemade bread that’s just as stellar.
Anselmo’s Pizzeria & Deli
$ | (914) 969-1949 | WEBSITE
Anselmo’s Pizzeria & Deli in Yonkers is a standout pizza spot (and one of our best pizza restaurants of 2026). It’s their latest year in the local scene, and they’ll have amazing Shrimp Scampi slices, excellent customizable meals, and a welcoming family atmosphere. To dine, there are always crowded tables.
Roma II Pizza
$ | (914) 423-5845 | WEBSITE
Proclaiming our love for Roma II Pizza in Yonkers is easy—this place serves fantastic, no-frills Italian classics like a crispy chicken parmigiana and perfectly baked ziti and rigatoni. In the neighborhood, they’re going a little more straightforward with delicious slices, friendly pickup service, and authentic pizza that’s described as the best ever.
Catania’s Pizzeria
$ | (914) 779-5105 | WEBSITE
Catania’s Pizzeria is Yonkers’ undisputed pizza champ. But the sleeper hit on their menu is the calzones. The hefty pockets are packed with meat and cheese fillings that ooze out with each bite. Both the pepperoni pizza and a mini calzone will be at your table, plus spaghetti and meatballs and traditional New York-style slices.
A & V Pizzeria
$ | (914) 423-3885 | WEBSITE
Sometimes, the simplest choice (and quickest bite) is a slice of pizza. The ones at A & V Pizzeria are a sure thing. The Yonkers spot is serving up classic pepperoni, savory sausage, and cheese slices, plus chicken parm sandwiches as a hearty option.
Doughboys Pizza
$ | (718) 708-5829 | WEBSITE
This Yonkers pizza joint is a local staple—that’s thanks to their thin, crunchy slices. These generously sized wedges of perfectly baked dough topped with flavorful sauce and cheese are making their way to breakfast tables, as are late-night cravings and regular lunch runs.
Casa Mia
$$ | (914) 327-4155 | WEBSITE
We’re big fans of whatever comes out of the kitchen at Casa Mia, the cozy and elegant restaurant in Yonkers. For their regular menu, they’re featuring seafood pasta in tomato sauce, fresh bruschetta, and their limoncello cake to go—one we never get tired of.
Palisades Pizza & Pasta
$$ | (914) 963-0127 | WEBSITE
The pizza from this cozy spot in Yonkers is on the shortlist of NY’s best. And it’ll be making an appearance at your next gathering in crispy crust form, along with pasta and ice cream.
Silvio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
$$ | (914) 476-2000 | WEBSITE
We look forward to Silvio’s garlic knots every visit. The Italian restaurant in Yonkers is back this season with their signature appetizer, brushed with so much garlic butter you could dip the extra into a cup and sip it like a broth. This time, they’re served with marinara sauce or a side of mozzarella sticks—and for the main course, there’s classic pizza.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
$ | (914) 961-8284 | WEBSITE
This Yonkers pizzeria serves some of the crispiest, most perfectly textured pizza in the region. The hot, thin crust emerges from the brick oven with a satisfying crunch, topped with classic combinations that highlight quality ingredients. Watching the skilled staff craft each pie before it arrives at your booth or table is entertainment in itself. Grabbing a slice with a cold beer before heading out for the evening should be high on your to-do list.
Michelangelo’s Pizza
$ | (914) 776-0360 | WEBSITE
This Yonkers pizza institution is behind some of the most consistently satisfying pies in Westchester (flaky crust and generous toppings, anyone?). For a quick lunch or family dinner, they’re serving up perfectly cooked pizza with that savory sauce, plus a lively atmosphere where the staff even play soccer inside the pizzeria.
La Lanterna Restaurant Wine & Beer Garden
$$ | (914) 476-3060 | WEBSITE
La Lanterna Restaurant Wine & Beer Garden serves the best Italian food in Yonkers, hands down. So the fact that they’re offering their spicy lobster & shrimp with pasta and grilled branzino all season should be the best dining news you’ll hear all month. Make time between outings to try them alongside their cheesy garlic bread and Italian donut with pepperoni and hot honey.
Giovanni’s Pizza
$ | (914) 375-1429 | WEBSITE
One likely weekend scenario: you’ve just watched the Yonkers marathon and need to refuel with something substantial. Giovanni’s Pizza, an Italian spot near Downtown Yonkers by the Saw Mill River, makes some of our favorite pies in the city. The exact toppings are still TBD, but whatever they are, you’ll want them.
Gino’s Pizzeria
$ | (914) 423-5088 | WEBSITE
There’s only one thing to order at Gino’s Pizzeria: the meat lovers pizza, regular or house pie, with that perfect sauce, just-right cheese, and toppings on a medium-thick crust. Devouring a whole slice while it’s still dripping is the smart way to spend a quick lunch break before heading back to work in Manhattan or Connecticut.
Pizza Bella
$ | (914) 968-6660 | WEBSITE
Pizza runs the show at this Italian spot. The Yonkers pizzeria will serve it with BBQ chicken or vegetarian options, plus a kid-friendly version with simple pasta. For a slightly more transportable dish, go for the fresh sandwiches or wraps.
Dunwoodie Pizzeria
$ | (914) 476-5008 | WEBSITE
If you’ve never had garlic knots that melt in your mouth, the streak ends here. Dunwoodie Pizzeria, a standout pizza spot in Yonkers, will be serving them up, as well as spicy pasta that’s out of this world and large pepperoni pizzas with a crunchy crust. The nostalgic atmosphere, with its warm lighting and cozy booths, makes every visit memorable. Friendly staff keep the experience smooth, while the great drink selection pairs perfectly with the symphony of flavors.
Prices hover around $20 for a large pizza, making it an affordable treat. Attention to detail shines through, from the freshly made knots to the authentic, delicious pies that keep customers coming back.
Capri Pizzeria
$ | (914) 969-5363 | WEBSITE
Capri Pizzeria is always dependable for old-school Sicilian pizza, with a cozy spot in Yonkers. Find their small shop to get their thick, heavy pie loaded with flavorful gravy and cheese, excellent calzones, and unbeatable prices. The delicious pies are perfect for takeout or a quick bite.
