Once you’ve exhausted Buffalo’s lakeside trails and antique shops, the culinary scene beckons as your next frontier. You’ll find more than just hearty Midwestern fare—though there’s plenty of that. What you’re really after are the standout restaurants, and Buffalo delivers with cozy taverns, farm-to-table gems, and spots where the walleye is always fresh and the craft beers flow freely.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (763) 684-1661 | WEBSITE
Papa Murphy’s is basically a neighborhood pizza fantasy where you can have a great meal without the fuss of cooking from scratch. Definitely grab one of their coupon codes from the online survey—it’ll get you deals like 25% off orders over $25. This is where you should pick up their signature Gourmet Vegetarian pizza, loaded with fresh veggies and gooey cheese.
Trying every single one of their pizza combinations during one visit is impossible, but the Gourmet Vegetarian is a great intro to their menu, made with quality ingredients and baked fresh at home. Sure, this is one of the pricier take-and-bake spots in the area, but you’ll see both families stocking up for game night and locals grabbing quick weeknight dinners. The store is clean and bright with plenty of parking nearby, and the staff is always friendly and efficient with your order.
Muffy’s Basement
$$ | (763) 682-8989 | WEBSITE
Hidden beneath Evelyn’s wine bar, Muffy’s Basement is a speakeasy that will be a sure hit with your friend who unironically describes themselves as a “cocktail connoisseur.” All the dark wood, vintage barware, and cozy seating come together under warm lighting, while the skilled bartenders craft perfect old fashioneds and other classic cocktails. The small space creates an intimate, fun atmosphere that feels like a secret escape, perfect for a night out with friends.
J’s Down Under
$ | (763) 355-9824 | WEBSITE
J’s Down Under is a cozy restaurant with a Speakeasy atmosphere, known for its motorcycle catering and live music on weekends. There are dark wood-paneled walls with vintage motorcycle memorabilia, concrete floors, and hanging light fixtures in the shape of old-fashioned lanterns. The lively spot centers around good conversation and entertainment, so grab a drink before enjoying the meat raffle or pull tabs, or karaoke on weekends.
The staff is generally friendly and courteous, with bartender Catie excelling in speed, friendliness, and mixology, providing an enjoyable and memorable experience. Although it can get crowded quickly, resulting in occasional service issues, the establishment remains wheelchair accessible, though the ramp is steep and narrow.
A&W Restaurant
$ | (763) 595-1405 | WEBSITE
At first glance the menu at A&W Restaurant seems straightforward, but it’s actually extremely satisfying. There’s a variety of classic options—including the Cod basket that’s highly recommended for fish lovers—on the menu. And even if you’re not in the habit of seeking out fast food, it’s hard not to be impressed by the friendly staff and quick service at work.
Their care goes toward burgers that are good and fresh—served with root beer that’s a highlight—and the polar swirls paired with shakes that include diet root beer for those watching their sugar. The restaurant’s cozy atmosphere is a hub for family meals, including kids meals that keep everyone happy.
Rancho Grande – Buffalo
$ | (763) 682-2929 | WEBSITE
Rancho Grande might be the best Mexican restaurant ever named after a ranch—look out for colorful papel picado banners hanging from the ceiling and don’t miss the vibrant mural of Mexican landscapes along the back wall. Diners happily spread out at comfortable tables in the spacious dining room flanked by a long, curved bar and a bustling open kitchen where you can watch tortillas being pressed.
Part family-friendly eatery, part authentic taqueria, the servers at Rancho Grande bring frosty margaritas and glasses of horchata to pair with generous plates that feel like they made the journey to your table by way of Mexico.
That means seafood fajitas sizzling with shrimp and scallops accompanied by grilled peppers and onions, beef and chicken fajitas nestled in warm flour tortillas with all the fixings, or tacos mahi mahi with perfectly seasoned fish cascading over fresh corn tortillas from their own kitchen.
Forget Me Not Cafe
$ | (763) 276-1977 | WEBSITE
The breakfast at Forget Me Not Cafe reminds us of a perfect morning. Technically a classic meal, but maybe better than homemade. Much of the menu is comforting takes on staples or elevated versions of familiar favorites—diners may have their standard eggs and toast, but thankfully, Forget Me Not’s spin on morning classics is exponentially tastier.
To round out the meal, order shareables like the Big Breakfast skillet with bacon, sausage, and ham, and the Cinnamon Roll French Toast with its sweet, indulgent appeal. It’s in a spacious, welcoming space with ample street parking, making it a great spot for both families and individuals looking for a relaxing start to the day.
What’s the Scoop? – Buffalo
$ | (763) 777-9166 | WEBSITE
This family-friendly ice cream spot has the backing of a local community supporter, who opened it after seeing the need for a charming destination in downtown Buffalo. Have a waffle cone with multiple scoops before heading outside, where you can choose between unique flavors like mint chocolate chip and caramel collision, or a lower-key sugar-free option for those with dietary restrictions.
Either way, spring for the soft-serve if it’s available, which includes a good portion size and great taste if the weather isn’t too hot. And you should always pick the caramel collision, which is the owner’s specialty—however it’s served, you need it in your cone. The welcoming staff and decent-sized parking lot make it a convenient way to enjoy Buffalo Lake’s scenic views by the scoop.
Culver’s
$ | (763) 682-5483 | WEBSITE
This reliable American comfort-food spot in Buffalo provides a straightforward and satisfying dining experience, with friendly and efficient service that makes every visit feel special. The clean and comfortable dining area sets the stage for consistently good food, including the veggie burger, chicken tenders, and the wonderful Strawberry Fields Salad, all served hot and in generous portions.
While there may be occasional mix-ups, like onions on a burger when they were requested not to be included, the overall experience remains positive. Instead of fancy cocktails, refresh yourself with classic sodas or milkshakes—the friendly staff will ensure you leave happy, at least for one meal.
House of Lo
$ | (763) 682-4100 | WEBSITE
When you first walk into House of Lo, your eyes might be underwhelmed. But all the takeout details come together in a focused simplicity that makes the space feel efficient and straightforward. There’s a simple counter for ordering, basic fluorescent lighting overhead, a small waiting area with plastic chairs, a menu board with handwritten specials, and a kitchen window that just so happens to be where all the delicious aromas emerge from the back of the space.
Bugambilias Cocina Latina
$ | (763) 276-7568 | WEBSITE
There’s no shortage of flavor here, but the menu covers all the classics, from bold and spicy la pollada to favorites like Fajitas and Los Tortuga’s. Skip the rush by timing a visit for a late lunch or early dinner so you’re relaxed enough to take in the welcoming atmosphere before heading out—especially with the friendly and attentive staff ensuring a smooth dining experience.
El Huichol Mexican Restaurant
$ | (763) 355-9535 | WEBSITE
A couple of chimichangas with that extra spicy salsa and a few plates of con birria and quesabirria tacos are enough to halt any conversation your table is having though. If you’re all ready to head out after the meal, grab a coffee or dessert right there at the restaurant—they’re included in the reasonable prices.
Jersey Mike’s
$ | (507) 888-2639 | WEBSITE
Jersey Mike’s has been around for years, and has been the neighborhood’s go-to, lunchtime sandwich spot for ages. Bright walls, simple decor, and a straightforward menu make it feel like a classic sub shop—only this one serves delicious sandwiches. Their classic Mike’s Way sandwiches are so good you’ll ask your friend if you can have the last bite (they’ll say yes, a sign friendship is not dead).
You’ll both be pleased with options like the customizable subs with fresh ingredients you’ll want to savor with every bite—a satisfying one, of course. And make sure you try the classic Italian after. If your afternoon is just beginning, grab a quick bite next door at the local coffee shop, where they have friendly baristas, comfortable seating, free Wi-Fi, and a relaxed atmosphere.
Evelyn’s Wine Bar
$$ | (763) 682-8989 | WEBSITE
Evelyn’s Wine Bar is one of the best and most reliable places for a cozy evening out in Buffalo. You’ll find delicious food beyond the standard fare, like the top-notch flatbreads or the fabulous Cookie Cheesecake. Finish off with a wine flight. While it’s a small, quiet boutique-style place, this one has a speakeasy in the basement with charming decor and fantastic drinks, and there’s a welcoming atmosphere for kids to enjoy while you dine.
Bison Creek Bar and Dining
$ | (763) 355-9620 | WEBSITE
The comfortable dining area offers a view of the arcade games and bowling lanes (they even have wheelchair accessibility throughout), though the restaurant is spacious enough inside to accommodate large gatherings and events. It’s the kind of spot that works for either impressing the family with a reunion or solo dining after you’ve been enjoying the kid-friendly atmosphere and salad bar.
Wild Marsh Grill
$ | (763) 682-4476 | WEBSITE
This tucked-away spot at the Buffalo golf course basically invites you to soak up the casual, friendly vibe and enjoy the surprisingly low prices. But what it lacks in reservation policies it makes up for in sheer value, with a straightforward approach to classic American comfort food.
The menu stays consistent, but current highlights include beef tacos with fresh ingredients and crispy shells—like your favorite taco truck’s more refined sibling who decided to settle down—and a satisfying, creamy BLT with avocado, layered with quality bacon and ripe tomatoes. Once you taste the garlic-parm fries with garlic aioli, crispier and more flavorful than the usual pub fries, you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even left.
